4 ms·
I agree with your design comments WRT approximately 0.1% (or less) of truly exotic level embedded work, like for military aerospace. That does not invalidate i
by VLM 14y ago
I agree with your design comments WRT approximately 0.1% (or less) of truly exotic level embedded work, like for military aerospace. That does not invalidate it for the other 99.9% of embedded devs.
To a greater or lesser extent its just fear of the unknown. I could subject your post to copy and paste conversion and it would ring true with the conversion from mech timers to electronic contro, or discretes to ICs, or microcode based CPUs, or SBC microprocessors to single chip SoC microcontrollers, etc. The industry will adjust, over time.
"Anyone in software has had the experience of using some open-source module to save time only to end-up paying for it dearly when something doesn't work correctly and help isn't forthcoming."
LOL write it yourself merely means you reinvent the wheel complete with having to discover and patch all the obvious bugs first, before you even begin to catch up to the hard bugs.
"simply wiring together a bunch of includes"
What I'm getting at, is much as no one would be crazy enough to write their own homemade Perl database driver instead of using the world's universal standard to do the job, no one in FPGA land is crazy enough to write their own Z80 core when the T80 core at opencores has about a decade of R+D, and more importantly debugging, behind it. Plus or minus crazy regulatory/licensing requirements of course.
"If you don't understand logic circuits FPGA's are voodoo"
Yes insane race conditions and clocking issues are "fun". Fast digital is very much analog that is hidden behind the curtain... "...ignore the man behind the curtain..." Then again my car transmission, my wife's coffee maker, my clothes dryer, my microwave, and my dishwasher will never, ever test the boundaries of modern digital logic speeds so we're back at the 99.9% vs 0.01% argument again.
"you can do nearly everything in web development via freely available includes."
Well, yeah. What I am getting at is writing your own homemade clone of script.aculo.us or buying an expensive clone of it would be a complete disaster compared to just including "the real thing" and using it.
- robomartin 14y agoYou've mentioned using processor cores a few times now. I'll assume, perhaps wrongly, that this might be a representation of your world when it comes to using FPGA's. That is not my world at all. My applications have never had the luxury of being able to simply import an 8 bit processor core and a few peripherals and off we go into software land. Nearly everything I've done has been in two domains: real time image processing in hardware or beam-forming applications. In all cases virtually no use of canned modules could be made or justified. Sure, there's the SPI's and I2C's and a few other knick-knacks, but that's about it. In fact, most of the applications I've done would end-up with external physical embedded processors because the high-speed FPGA resources could not be spared for low speed "command and control" work. Maybe I'm living in that 0.1% you referred to? Surely there are people doing more mundane things such as motor control, glue logic or battery chargers who might benefit from wiring together a complete custom embedded system within single Spartan FPGA and life is great. I can see that being a possibility. It just hasn't been part of my reality, for better or worst.