You are mischaracterizing my argument. I'm saying this: 1) This movie is available for sale. 2) I want to purchase it. 3) Therefore, they are obligated to sell

You are mischaracterizing my argument. I'm saying this: 1) This movie is available for sale. 2) I want to purchase it. 3) Therefore, they are obligated to sell it to me. Or, alternatively, I feel I am entitled to purchase a copy. This is what I fundamentally disagree with. I do not believe that you have any sort of right to purchase a product. Just because they make it available for sale does not mean that they are in any way obligated to sell it to you, even if you want it very badly and are willing to pay quite a lot of money. I'm not actually talking about torrenting at all; that comes after the 'entitlement'.