3 ms·
I am paraphrasing the two quotes: You can say there is a 25% increase in chance of dying if you smoke. You cannot say there is a 25% chance that the nur
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
I am paraphrasing the two quotes:
You can say there is a 25% increase in chance of dying
if you smoke. You cannot say there is a 25% chance that
the nurse murdered those people - she either did or did
not. (what we lack is the knowledge of the past event)
second para:
On the preponderance of evidence, the court believes
beyond a reasonable doubt that the nurse *did* kill those
people. That event A *did* happen - we have used evidence
to fill in the gaps of our knowledge.
We are not assigning a probability to it, but we recognise
that life is all probabilities, but thats what reasonable
doubt it all about.
I think that those two quotes (modified as I understand them) are consistent. They are also not entirely Bayesian but I would prefer to be in a court of law than a court of probability.
- bo1024 14y agoHmmm, I guess I agree. But I think a Bayesian would argue that this is an argument over wording not meaning. If we formulate beliefs and act on beliefs, then how we want to word it doesn't make a difference.