4 ms·
Being able to dump the ISP would require a marketplace of ISPs to choose from. However, in the US, regulatory capture has prevented such a marketplace from form
by epistasis 14y ago
Being able to dump the ISP would require a marketplace of ISPs to choose from. However, in the US, regulatory capture has prevented such a marketplace from forming.
- shmerl 14y agoIs this regulatory capture still in force? And if not, what prevents them from forming now?
- olefoo 14y agoShort answer: Physics and Economics. Any new entrant has to build out a cable plant to reach subscribers and capture enough subscribers at a high enough density to make it worthwhile. The only company that's even trying at this point is Google.
- pyre 14y ago1. I presume that the capital costs of infrastructure in creating a new ISP are significant. 2. Most of the larger markets are in densely populated cities, which makes laying infrastructure even more difficult (there's a reason that Verizon rolled out FiOS to suburban areas rather than urban areas). 3. If your 'value added' is something that the ISPs can easier undercut to drive you out of business (e.g. expanding bandwidth caps, increasing speeds), then your business proposition becomes even shakier.
- epistasis 14y agoYes, typically cable companies have been granted monopolies within a municipality. In municipalities where cable companies have refused to upgrade infrastructure, and municipalities have attempted to build out fiber infrastructure to homes, cable companies have used the courts to delay movement by the municipality. Cable companies have also been pushing through laws on the state level to prevent municipalities from ever building out their own data infrastructure.
- epistasis 14y agoTurns out that I'm wrong on the municipal monopoly, that was changed in 1992 [1], and I was mistakenly perpetuating a common misconception. [1] http://www.muninetworks.org/content/cable-monopoly-result-private-sector-not-public http://www.muninetworks.org/content/cable-monopoly-result-pr...
- 27182818284 14y agoMy immediate thoughts exactly. The other competitor in my area currently can't go beyond 12 mbps down while TWC offers 20 mbps down and more. There was a young upstart I had high hopes for, but I was out of their area. They are http://www.widerangebroadband.net/ http://www.widerangebroadband.net/ and their customer service was great, but unfortunately I'm just outside their area at the moment.
- PeterisP 14y agoWhat use is theoretical "20mbps" if the real speed that you get isn't even suitable for youtube?
- 27182818284 14y ago20mbps from TWC is fine for YouTube for me. I don't seem to have the filtering problems the others have. I also stream Netflix fine. Sometimes the HTML5 player glitches, but that's about all I can report. Another part I didn't mention above is that the 20mbps plan bumps me to a higher up-speed plan, making remote work less laggy, etc.