3 ms·
Dude. You're in the library. Just get your stupid book and go read it? Why the deal with analyzing everything people might say to you? (grin) I'm at a similar
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Dude. You're in the library. Just get your stupid book and go read it? Why the deal with analyzing everything people might say to you? (grin)
I'm at a similar loss here -- your post is about anti-admiration. The community here is hackers -- people who break the rules in order to advance society by building something of value. If we were interested in conforming we'd be "IBM News" or "News for People Who Don't Disagree Much" -- both of which would be soundly boring. We'd also be some place like reddit, where herd mentality rules a great bit more than here (but it's still quite prevalent here as well).
I've seen quite a bit of mindless adoration on here, not especially for pg, but for a lot of prominent internet writers. We all know them. Famous Joe the writer could post his grocery list and it'd have 15 points and a dozen comments by tomorrow morning. I guess it's just something about being a public figure. Steven King did a nice essay about this a while back but the link escapes me. Plus, as I've pointed out before, having a hero is a completely normal thing to do. When you're 16 or 17 its critical to have somebody to idolize that is worth a damn. Once you get older that need doesn't go away, but you're able to synthesize the best of multiple people, something that isn't so easy to do with limited experience.
I think you hit the problem dead on: if you're thinking "gosh! It's PG! Why would I disagree with him?" (or agree, for that matter) then you've already lost it. Praise is great, but just react normally and don't worry about who the person is. It's the value of the idea, not the value of the person.
There was an article on here a while back about the difference between people who really succeed and those who get stuck. The gist of it was that if you can't treat everybody, including people who can help you a great deal, as equals, then they'll never think of you as an equal either.
Good essay! Made me think. And you're spot on about GED. Great book. :)
- khafra 18y agoI'm going to speak out in favor of discrimination: I can't treat everybody as equals. It's an information-rich world out there, and I don't have time to read or learn even a fraction of a percent of what I'd like to. One way I filter is by topic. I maintain a reddit account, but I subscribe to subreddits that interest me. URL acts as another filter--if it starts with news.ycombinator.com/ or overcomingbias.com/, for example, there's a higher probability I want to read it. I apply "author" below these filters. I use reddit's "friend" feature liberally for users with a history of knowledgeable, insightful comments so I can pick them out quickly. On other sites, I just get to know usernames and pay attention to them. PG may have abandoned the "valuable user" highlighting, but I still do it mentally. I'm sure I miss some valuable information that way, but there's not much else I can do but keep donating to SIAI and working on startup ideas until PG and Yudkowsky get together, write an FAI in Arc, and solve all the world's problems.