2 ms·
I don't actually think this policy will have the desired effect of improving privacy and similar. While I do think advertisers and analytics abuse third-party
by JoshTriplett 14y ago
I don't actually think this policy will have the desired effect of improving privacy and similar.
While I do think advertisers and analytics abuse third-party cookies, they also have a dozen other things they can switch to that the browser provides fewer facilities to control: http://samy.pl/evercookie/ http://samy.pl/evercookie/
Meanwhile, any legitimate services that rely on third-party cookies would have little choice but to switch to whatever mechanism the advertisers switch to, to remain functional.
- eric-hu 14y agoWhat are legitimate uses of third party cookies? Not trying to be snarky or sarcastic, I'm just unaware.
- elehack 14y agoLogging in to services like Disqus, for one thing.
- Amadou 14y agoI agree, I think it is just a small escalation in the arms race. Personally, I'd rather have tools that pollute the data being collected rather than just blocking it. Imagine a firefox add-on that keeps entirely seperate "cookie jars" based on referrer. So if you visited 100 different websites you would have a 100 different cookies for any particular advertising network, each one unique to the specific website you were looking at.