4 ms·
There's several points to this article. At first it's about cult followings, but then it morphs into a self-examination of the consequences of being a public fi
by swombat 18y ago
There's several points to this article. At first it's about cult followings, but then it morphs into a self-examination of the consequences of being a public figure. Finally, Eliezer ends with a question about the impulse to praise someone highly.
1) There is an enormous difference between "having a cult-like following" and "having a cult". Anyone who argues that Startup School is some sort of cult facility for churning out brainwashed followers is just plain dumb. Fortunately, I've never seen anyone admit such an opinion, so hopefully they don't exist.
2) When you choose to become a public figure, like both Eliezer and PG have done, you do give up a certain element of privacy. This applies as much to intellectual figures (like pg, Einstein or Feynman) as to more common ones (like Angelina Jolie, Tony Blair or Stephen Fry). That is part of the deal. Some people can't take it and so they attempt to escape the public life. Others can. But all make that trade-off between private life and public recognition.
3) Writing an article or a public comment about how to become a writer is not the same thing as wandering into the library to pick a book. When pg writes an article and publishes it, that is a public statement. It is perfectly reasonable that it gathers public feedback from a large number of people. Comments are also completely public, and in a format that encourages interaction. If you don't want to interact with your readers, you don't have to. But if you choose to, you cannot complain that they will sometimes disagree with you in bizarre ways.
4) One of the consequences of interacting with a large number of people is that some of them will disagree with you for the sake of disagreeing. Again, that's life... Every "mainstream" figure has contrarians who will criticise them just because they define themselves in that way. If you can't take it, don't be a public figure. Hopefully, the 90% of ppl who do think you're great make up for the 10% who want to disagree with everything you say.
- Eliezer 18y agoWell, I'd agree that both PG and I have "cult followings" but that's not at all the same as "cult-like followings". I should mention that this post is part of a series on things that prevent nonconformists from cooperating (http://lesswrong.com/lw/3h/why_our_kind_cant_cooperate/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/3h/why_our_kind_cant_cooperate/). You're right, this sort of thing is personally uncomfortable for me, and you're right, I did volunteer for that in the course of allowing myself to become a public figure. But it also has consequences for the larger community.
- swombat 18y agoI read that article and was going to reply earlier, but HN was down... (all because of you, writing that recursive article...) You make a very interesting point there (more than in this article, in fact, imho). My thought on it is that there is a spectrum of techniques to "engage" groups of people and elicit desired behaviour. Some of them work, and some of them don't. Some of them are towards the Dark Side, and some of them closer to the Light Side. I think it's incorrect to suppose that only the techniques on the Dark Side work. Light Side techniques work too, but differently. And Dark Side techniques have a cost too, which is not always obvious. Raelians may be very good at generating agreement and coordinated behaviour, but what creativity do they have? The brainwashing ensures that there is little original, individual thought left. For example, the technique used by your synagogue seems like a good technique, not unethical, but very effective. I haven't given it too much thought, but I suspect that a good way to draw the line is to examine whether a technique merely encourages or whether it coerces. Finally, do we "atheist/libertarian/technophile/sf-fan/early-adopter/programmer/etc" fail at organising ourselves? I don't think it's fair to say that. Considering the cooperative achievements we've achieved, starting with the operating system that this site no doubt runs on, I'd say we're doing quite well on the whole. And in the long run, that matters more.
- jibiki 18y agoWould you feel that people were doing you a disservice if their admiration for you prevented them from honestly evaluating your arguments?
- Eliezer 18y agoYes.
- dasil003 18y agoYour critique is fair, but I have to say I really enjoyed the library analogy, flawed though it may be. I was fascinated by the mental image of groups of people behaving that way in public.
- vinutheraj 18y agoI saw an interesting clip of Murray Gellmann talking about Feynman. He, surprisingly says that initially it was good to work with Feynman, with all his independent thinker stuff and all, but in the end it started getting on his nerves. Feynman used to defy authority just for the sake of it. The place where they worked had a dress code for their mess hall, it was a suit and tie I think, so what Feynamn used to do was that he a special worn out shirt and jacket he used to wear in the mess hall even if he had come in that day wearing a suit and tie. Then Gellmann goes onto say that Feynman used to spend a lot of his time generating anecdotes about himself, for which Feynman is really famous. Murray says, Feynman always wanted to be different, he even didn't brush or floss his teeth! Feynman kept saying that brushing and flossing teeth and washing hands after toilet was superstition. Well this seemed a good example of a someone famous, having a cult(-like) following, who has been accused of not conforming just for the sake of it. Maybe the cult got to Feynman in the end. Anyway I feel that Feynman rocks and thankyou for inspiring me. Here is the clip for the interested - http://www.edge.org/video/dsl/gell-mann.html http://www.edge.org/video/dsl/gell-mann.html
- jamesbritt 18y ago"Well this seemed a good example of a someone famous, having a cult(-like) following, who has been accused of not conforming just for the sake of it. Maybe the cult got to Feynman in the end." I've known a number of people who've been accused of not conforming just for the sake of it. I don't think any had a cult following; it was just their nature. That seems to have been the case with Feynman, not an affectation because of fame. (Of course, I know of Feynman mostly through his own writings ...) People have their quirks. Feynman rocks no matter what. The world could use more pranksters and skeptics.