5 ms·
I'm not sure I understand the specific complaints in the post. The metadata in iTunes is stored in a standard way, attached to the audio files themselves. All t
by epistasis 14y ago
I'm not sure I understand the specific complaints in the post. The metadata in iTunes is stored in a standard way, attached to the audio files themselves. All the playlists, repeated track infromation, etc, is stored in an XML file with simple structure. This should be as easy to convert as if the music database had been stored anywhere else.
Similarly, for iPhoto, much of the metadata is attached to the photos themselves. The album information is in very simple XML. I'm not sure how the cropping, rotation, etc, are stored, but the final JPEG can be exported from the UI, and nearly all these applications are highly scriptable.
Storing data in any application results in some restrictions in how that data can be transformed and/or used in the future. The iApps use fairly transparent data formats that are accessible to pretty much any programmer. I'm not sure if there's any open source alternatives to these apps that make it much easier to pull out data. Putting data in these apps is not mortgaging your future as much as putting your documents in MS Office format, for example.
- crististm 14y ago"Storing data in any application results in some restrictions [...]" - I think you understand her point pretty well.
- crusso 14y agoNo, because the author mentioned that it's some kind of Mac problem. You'd have the exact same problems switching from "free" software running on Linux. Really, I think the article should have been titled: I am Now Dependent on Modern Technology and Don't Like the Alternative
- crististm 14y agoNo, what? You end up confirming what I said: it's an application issue - be it free or proprietary. But in her case, phone syncing in a proprietary world is more of a problem. I think she meant it like "I'm dependent on MAC Technology and I can't get out".
- rosser 14y ago(FYI, an appreciable number of the downvotes you're receiving are probably because you're consistently using male pronouns for the author of a post on rachelbythebay.com. You might want to fix that, and your assumptions...)
- crististm 14y agoThanks
- coldtea 14y agoAnd what if it's a male called Rachel? (Like the "boy named Sue"). Or this guy: http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1290&dat=19900628&id=-9tOAAAAIBAJ&sjid=_4wDAAAAIBAJ&pg=4348,5031260 http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1290&dat=19900628&...
- rosser 14y agoIt's not. Rachel's posts have shown up on HN often enough that this isn't even a question any more.
- rachelbythebay 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor
- crusso 14y agoYou're assuming an abstraction of what she posted and claiming that's what she meant as her point. Her use of Mac/Apple/iTunes/Jobs as specific references without explicitly making the point you're making mean that we can't logically rely on your assumption.
- coldtea 14y agoNo, he doesn't, and I don't too. How would that be different with any Open Source application? There is NO common interchange format for music information besides the embedded mp3 metadata. Of course iTunes (and ANY other player, OSS or not) has to store non-standard stuff outside those. And even if it stored them inside, there is no consensus about the naming and interoperability for metadata not in the standard list. So there's nothing in her points that can be particularly applied to Apple or iTunes. It just makes no sense to say "I'm going to use Ubuntu mp3 players because of this" -- because the situation there would be the same.
- DanBC 14y ago> How would that be different with any Open Source application? In theory the Unix way is to have plain text as input and output. This has meant that many open source softwares use nice plain text files for their data storage stuff.
- coldtea 14y agoThere is no Unix way after circa 1997. In the olden days, the Unices had some coherence and core principle. After the OSS explosion at the end of the nineties that doesn't hold true anymore. For example all the Gnome/KDE apps are not combinable command line utils with GUI front ends, but backend+GUI apps in one. And the architecture, UX and ways they use are far from what the UNIX of old used. For example Gnome/KDE were directly inspired from MS Windows (first) and from OS X (in subsequent versions), to the point that traditional UNIX users complained. >In theory the Unix way is to have plain text as input and output. This has meant that many open source softwares use nice plain text files for their data storage stuff. iTunes also used a plain XML file for its database. IIRC, it has moved it to binary plist files for performance reasons several versions ago.
- spindritf 14y ago> Storing data in any application results in some restrictions in how that data can be transformed and/or used in the future. And not all applications are equal in that regard. I store plenty of data in Dropbox, never run into any problems. Same with git, mutt, Shotwell, Rhythmbox... Usually, exporting doesn't involve any action. All the data is just stored in files that can be used by any application. There is a strong correlation between free software and convenient data formats. Why pretend that all software has those same problems to a similar degree?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nirvana 14y agoExcept that in the case of all the data she's complaining about the Apple products DO use conveneint data formats. The MP3 structure supports tags in the files as a standard going back to the 1990s and Apple supports it. I don't think Linux storing MP3s in a directory is superior to iTunes storing them in a directory structure (organized by artist name).