3 ms·
And is the average response time of a police officer to your home, less than a minute, everywhere in the UK, any time of day or night, regardless of any other c
by mindcrime 14y ago
And is the average response time of a police officer to your home, less than a minute, everywhere in the UK, any time of day or night, regardless of any other circumstance?
If not, maybe you lot should reconsider your irrational fear of guns.
FWIW, the USA is much larger than England, and some of our rural areas are very rural, so it's hardly an apples to apples comparison... but just to illustrate a bit: I was a 911 dispatcher for a while some years ago. The county I dispatched for was one of the larger ones (by square mileage) in NC, and mostly rural. Law enforcement was provided by the county sheriff's department, as well as town police forces from the 9 or 10 incorporated towns which were large enough to have their own police force.
On an average night shift, there would be 4 sheriff's deputies plus a sargeant on patrol. That's 5 people, plus the one or two town cops from each town. Now this is to cover a county where driving all the way from one end to the other, north/south down Highway 17, would take about an hour, and crossing the county east/west along Highway 211 could take a good 45 minutes.
So what do you think the response time for a cop was, if you dialed 911 at 3:00am and happened to live out near the Brunswick/Columbus county line? Well, if the "area 3" deputy happened to have been on an earlier call that took him down towards Southport, you were looking at probably 45 minutes. What if he was actively tied up on another call? Now you have to ask somebody from another district to respond, or get one of the town officers to respond. And they're even further away.
Interestingly enough, even in big cities with much greater population density and more police officers, you still can't (except by blind chance) expect a particularly fast response time for a cop. Certainly not fast enough if someone with ill intentions is creeping around outside your home.
The simple truth is, the idea of police responding to a life threatening emergency, and arriving in time to stop it before anyone is harmed, is a myth. Police exist to A. act as a deterrent, and B. respond after the fact and attempt to locate the perpetrators.
- tome 14y agoI think you're responding to a point of view I didn't express (and don't hold) but thank you for sharing your experience. In any case, what "police exist" to do depends very much on the jurisdiction they serve in. The situation outside the US is very different from the one inside the US. Please bear that in mind before asserting that your interlocutor has an "irrational fear of guns".
- mindcrime 14y agoIn any case, what "police exist" to do depends very much on the jurisdiction they serve in. Perhaps, but I bet you'll be hard pressed to find any jurisdiction (in reality) where police actually serve to respond to - and stop - in progress crimes on a routine basis. And I guess you'd be even harder pressed to find one of those where they actually live up to that standard. Please bear that in mind before asserting that your interlocutor has an "irrational fear of guns". I'm generalizing, of course, which is somewhat intellectually lazy, but in the absence of other evidence, it's a reasonable shortcut in the conversation. My experience has been that when someone identifies themselves as being from the UK, and takes a largely "anti gun" position, they usually have some pretty whacked out beliefs about guns and gun ownership. If that's not the case here, you have my apologies.
- tome 14y agoI think you'll find that beliefs about guns and gun ownership in the UK are fairly commensurate with the western world as a whole. It's the US that bucks the trend on this issue (as it does with many others). "Whacked out" seems like an unfair description; "inappropriate for application to the reality of the US" seems more reasonable.