4 ms·
(I'll answer in the most crude general terms without aiming for nuance just to give you an idea of the culture here. Of course the reality is much more detaile
by tome 14y ago
(I'll answer in the most crude general terms without aiming for nuance just to give you an idea of the culture here. Of course the reality is much more detailed than I can describe in a few paragraphs and what I say is only true to the coarsest approximation.)
UK residents are simply not afraid of being shot, because there are so few firearms. Armed robberies (with guns and with other weapons) do happen and as I understand it the generally accepted procedure is that you give the robber the material goods that he wants and then he goes away.
Violent physical attacks do take place too, of course, though (without looking at the statistics) I would estimate they happen far less frequently than the US. Even when such crimes cause outrage, civilian gun ownership is never suggested as a means of reducing the crime rate.
Public policy in the UK is far more focused on reducing the number of attempts at violent crime than it is focused on giving individual citizens the ability to defend themselves from such crimes at the moment they take place.
- mindcrime 14y agoEven when such crimes cause outrage, civilian gun ownership is never suggested as a means of reducing the crime rate. I wouldn't say "never". http://www.armbritain.com/forum/index.php http://www.armbritain.com/forum/index.php
- tome 14y agoA pithy response, but could you flesh it out more? In particular, are you suggesting that this organisation has any sort of substantial following? If you make your claim explicit I can disabuse you of any misconceptions you maybe carrying.
- mindcrime 14y agoYou said "never". I provided a counter-example which disproves your argument that private gun ownership for self defence is never suggested. In particular, are you suggesting that this organisation has any sort of substantial following? I have no idea, but that's hardly the point. If they had even one member, it shows that private gun ownership is, indeed, sometimes suggested.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nitrogen 14y agoThis lack of fear is interesting, because Britain's violent crime rate is higher than the US. "Swann noted that in the UK, there are 2,034 violent crimes per 100,000 people. By contrast, there are 466 violent crimes per 100,000 here in America." - http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2013/01/10/fox-affiliate-thoroughly-debunks-piers-morgan-s-gun-homicide-statisti http://newsbusters.org/blogs/noel-sheppard/2013/01/10/fox-af... (I couldn't find a list of countries on Wikipedia sorted by violent crime, only by intentional homicide, so this is the best source I could cite in the time available for making this comment) Edit to add: I believe that abandoning fear of negative outcomes is the solution to many of our problems, not tightening the reins on society to try to prevent negative outcomes.
- tome 14y agoI would be interested to see a breakdown. The received wisdom we have over here is that the UK is far safer in terms of violent crime than the US, but perhaps this perception is wrong.
- nitrogen 14y agoThe number of intentional homicides that I found was higher for the US, so that may be where the perception arises. Unfortunately it appears that these statistics haven't been broken down in an easy to use format, or if they have, it's hidden in some corner of the web where Google and Wikipedia dare not tread.
- RobAley 14y agoAs a former UK police officer, I can tell you that UK violent crime stats usually include any kind of crime that includes legally defined force, e.g. - "common assault" (includes slapping, spitting at, pushing) - threats of violence - domestic/marital violence - physical abuse i.e. not just "stranger" violence and physical situations where people are not injured. My guess, for the US statistics to be so low, they may not include similar crimes. Many countries only include so-called "serious" assaults in their stats. Also, UK figures usually include all reported crimes, whether investigated and/or proven, or not.
- giardini 14y ago"UK residents are simply not afraid of being shot, because there are so few firearms." Perhaps because they're more concerned with getting stabbed! I see that some British doctors are calling for kitchen knife control: http://frontpagemag.com/2012/dgreenfield/british-doctors-call-for-ban-on-long-kitchen-knives-to-end-stabbings/ http://frontpagemag.com/2012/dgreenfield/british-doctors-cal... "the generally accepted procedure is that you give the robber the material goods that he wants and then he goes away." How do you instruct your wife or children to respond to rapists or pedophiles? Indeed, how would you respond?
- tome 14y ago(Again it's a broad overgeneralisation but ...) People in the UK are simply not so scared of rape or paedophilia that they want to wield the power of life or death over everyone they meet.