2 ms·
How do revolutions happen even in countries without mass individual gun ownership then? Remember that we're not talking about merely an insurgency here, we're
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
How do revolutions happen even in countries without mass individual gun ownership then?
Remember that we're not talking about merely an insurgency here, we're talking about an insurgency with massive popular support, against a government that has turned tyrannical. In such a situation there is no technological or firepower advantage that guarantees victory to the state, even nuclear weapons. There are always points of weakness, which can be exploited best by folks backed by extensive popular support locally. An uprising of ubiquitously armed civilians would be able to quickly overpower police forces, and they'd also be able to take over some military bases, gaining access to more powerful weapons. There would also likely be defections from military forces.
Look at Syria as an example, the regime there is ruthless and willing even to use mass carpet bombing and shelling on civilian targets, and there is no right to private gun ownership there, and yet somehow the rebels have managed to arm themselves not just with small arms but also RPGs, mortars, and tanks. Facilitating the early stages of a rebellion vastly accelerates all of the later stages. Moreover, mass civilian ownership of firearms means that the ability of police and armed forces to attack the public without fear of injury becomes much diminished, which provides a deterrent effect against such attacks.
- notdrunkatall 14y agoObviously the absence of guns do not make it impossible to stage a revolt; they do, however, make it much more difficult.
- introspect 14y agoI understand your argument, but help me understand, where do you draw the line in the types of "arms" that can be legal today? Would you support private ownership of such "RPGs, mortars and tanks"? How about the anti-aircraft projectiles that the Syrians rebels are so desperate to obtain? All these things would help me immensely when fighting a tyrannical government.