3 ms·
As another American, I don't think that's quite it, as we (Americans) have essentially given up some of your other rights: we don't really have a right to be se
by bediger4000 14y ago
As another American, I don't think that's quite it, as we (Americans) have essentially given up some of your other rights: we don't really have a right to be secure against arbitrary search and seizure any more, and we don't have much of a right to due process any more. We're shaving our freedom of speech thinner too.
So: why is the 4th Amendment right to keep and bear arms defended so zealously, and interpreted so liberally, when the wording around other rights, which are quite clear and simple, is interpreted in a non-obvious, often seemingly irrational manner so as to prevent people from exercizing those rights?
- damoncali 14y agoBecause power, as Mao said, comes from the barrel of a gun. Without the 2nd, the other amendments may as well be suggestions.
- noahc 14y ago2nd Amendment, actually. I agree on everything else.
- zaphar 14y agoPerhaps because the 2nd amendment is their last defense against the erosion of those other rights completely. See: American Revolutionary War
- bediger4000 14y agoRight, but "last defense" shouldn't constitute our only defense. Shouldn't all freedom-loving Americans speak out and vote against shaving protections against arbitrary search and seizure paper thin? Shouldn't all freedom-loving Americans vote against politicians who support things like universal wiretapping, dragnet searches and presumption of guilt in airports and at borders? In short, I don't believe that having a gun is any kind of last defense against loss of rights. I'll believe that when I see Waye LaPierre denouncing airport nude-a-trons, or when the Rocky Mountain Gun Owners actively join suit against the US DoJ for warrantless wiretapping.