4 ms·
Its made up of both actually. Somebody outside devops would consider pervasive use of sed, awk and other unix text processing utilities line noise. Yet such a t
by kamaal 14y ago
Its made up of both actually. Somebody outside devops would consider pervasive use of sed, awk and other unix text processing utilities line noise. Yet such a thing would come naturally to that person working on it daily.
If you can't really get such stuff easily at the very first time does it mean you are a bad programmer?
Not quite.
The way I look at it, I would consider somebody good if he can read the documentation/theory etc and then come up solution to problems(read: can write programs). That way you know the guy can actually get some work done. It requires practice and time to get used to and comfortable to a new domain. That's natural friction you have to wear out. Regardless of whether its math, music, literature of whatever. Paying too much importance to factual stuff isn't of much use. What's more important is, can the person work his way out of the problem.
I checked out your bio, I understand you do math for a living and are obviously a little defensive when some one underplays the importance of your area of expertise. But the fact of the matter is though math is relevant, the areas in which its relevant are largely either rare or are already solved and presented to most programmers as libraries and frameworks. And if its not, simple analysis, a little reading and experimenting is sufficient to solve the problem at hand.
Your problem is not with programmers but with a term called abstraction. And fighting that is futile. The benefits vastly over weight any intellectual argument you can present against it.
EDIT: By the way after reading your bio, I have developed atmost respect for all the work you have done in your life.
- srean 14y agoWas a fine tangential comment, till you started an unsolicited diagnosis of Colin's hypothetical disease. Downvoted.
- kintamanimatt 14y agoHuh? What hypothetical disease?
- ColinWright 14y agoHe said: Your problem is not with programmers but with a term called abstraction. And fighting that is futile. The benefits vastly over weight any intellectual argument you can present against it. Utterly bizarre, to be claiming that a pure mathematician has a problem with abstraction.
- kintamanimatt 14y agoWhy would that be a disease though? I thought he'd maybe edited his reply and said something else. Maybe I'm just tangled up in the misuse of a word though! Side note, does the theory of juggling have a mathematical underpinning?
- ColinWright 14y agoI have no idea why it would be a "disease", but he did seem to be diagnosing my attitude or "problem." Don't care. And yes, there is a great deal of mathematics underneath the structures of juggling patterns. Using them we predicted the existence of previously unknown juggling patterns, and have now used the math to create a proof that of all the juggling tricks of a certain type, we know them all (for some definition of "to know").
- srean 14y agoIt was supposed to be a metaphor, intended to highlight that no such disease is present and nor was it necessary to go about trying to diagnose what "the problem" with Colin was. diagnose <-> disease It clearly did not work as intended.
- Schwolop 14y agoYes, juggling patterns can be expressed neatly by the use of fairly simple mathematics. Look up "siteswap" or "siteswap notation". (It's also closely related to the mathematics of bell-ringing or "chiming".)
- ColinWright 14y agoThis is an utterly bizarre comment, and I have absolutely no idea what to make of it. It seems mostly non-sequitur, and then gets things exactly the wrong way round. I really don't know how to respond - it's almost perverse. However, there appears to be such a depth of misunderstanding, or non-understanding, I feel compelled to try ... Having read, re-read, and re-re-read your comment, let me say this. You appear to completely misunderstand the point. I'm not talking about mathematical ideas that have been taken, used, programmed, and made available through libraries. I'm talking about recognizing problems and techniques when they turn up unexpectedly, and in disguise. Many, many times in my 30 years as a working programmer have I found elegant solutions to previously intractable problems, purely because I recognized some sort of weird mathematical structure lurking underneath. It's my specialty to go into a situation where the domain experts have worked to solve a problem, sometimes for years, to have them explain the problem to me, and then to bring different insights and tools to bear on the problem. I'm not necessarily more clever, or more capable, I just have a different toolbox. And when the problem at hand is unusual, my toolbox is particularly powerful. You said: Somebody outside devops would consider pervasive use of sed, awk and other unix text processing utilities line noise. Yet such a thing would come naturally to that person working on it daily. I have no idea what point you're trying to make here. If you can't really get such stuff easily at the very first time does it mean you are a bad programmer? Not quite. Of course it doesn't. Different programmers have different skill sets, and different experience. Someone who doesn't know databases or web programming may be a wonderfully productive programmer in another area of specialization. I have no idea what relevance this has to my comment. The way I look at it, I would consider somebody good if he can read the documentation/theory etc and then come up solution to problems (read: can write programs). That way you know the guy can actually get some work done. It requires practice and time to get used to and comfortable to a new domain. That's natural friction you have to wear out. Regardless of whether its math, music, literature of whatever. Paying too much importance to factual stuff isn't of much use. What's more important is, can the person work his way out of the problem. Perhaps. My point is that people often dismiss mathematics as useless to programmers because they can't see how this lemma or that theorem can ever be relevant. My point is that the methods of thought trained by the study of advanced mathematics has, in my experience and others', regularly led to deep insights in apparently unrelated problem domains. This ability is not something you can "just read up on." This isn't a case of reading documentation and/or existing theory - this is a case of seeing something as being a disguised example of something else. I've lost count of the number of times I've recognized a matching problem, or a topological separation, or an abstract vector space, or a group acting on a metric space, and that recognition has subsequently led to a new solution. I checked out your bio, I understand you do math for a living and are obviously a little defensive when some one underplays the importance of your area of expertise. But the fact of the matter is though math is relevant, the areas in which its relevant are largely either rare or are already solved and presented to most programmers as libraries and frameworks. And if its not, simple analysis, a little reading and experimenting is sufficient to solve the problem at hand. Then, with respect, your experience appears to be limited, and your opinions parochial. Your problem is not with programmers but with a term called abstraction. And fighting that is futile. The benefits vastly over weight any intellectual argument you can present against it. This is just bizarre. I'm a pure mathematician - how can you suggest my problem is with abstraction? How can you possibly think I'm offering any argument against abstraction?