4 ms·
> Let me take the counterpoint: If peer review was a rubber stamping process then most journals or conference would publish most papers. False. Rubber-stamping
by lutusp 14y ago
> Let me take the counterpoint: If peer review was a rubber stamping process then most journals or conference would publish most papers.
False. Rubber-stamping is a two-way street. Some deserving papers are not published, some that are not deserving are. Examples of both kinds abound.