3 ms·
Then I was lead astray by the comment about the engine being 1/2 the size of a shipping container. Where is the source of that speculation and how informed is i
by dalke 14y ago
Then I was lead astray by the comment about the engine being 1/2 the size of a shipping container. Where is the source of that speculation and how informed is it?
How much energy can you get from a pulsed beam of charged particles? What's the efficiency level? The same question applies to getting power from X-rays. Photovoltaic is what, 20% at best? Certainly X-ray isn't that efficient.
Which means 5 MW of electrical generation is going to require, what, 20 MW of input power? 500 MW? No matter what, it's going to require a lot of cooling. Enough that saying that it fits into a container doesn't make sense.
And in any case, my statement was "We don't think it's possible to get fusion power to an even smaller scale [than a large ship's diesel engines]." You said "Some of the designs are pretty small-scale", but your example is already my example of a possible valid smaller scale.
So I think this is a case of one of those arguments where we're both on the same side?
- DennisP 14y agoYes maybe we are :) Here's a diagram showing the energy flow they expect, if things work out: http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/index.php?option=com_lyftenbloggie&view=entry&year=2012&month=02&day=01&id=55%3Aunderstand-the-focus-fusion-energy-flow&Itemid=90 http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/index.php?option=com_l... Overall energy balance of focus fusion reactors would be somewhat marginal, nothing like the 100x to 1000x that Sandia's talking about for MagLIF. In this diagram they mention "garage-size." The "onion" is photoelectric, not photovoltaic.
- dalke 14y agoThe tricky point is the "80% energy efficiency recovery from the beam and X-ray pulse." That seems incredibly high, and it lacks any references. All I could find in my limited search was this paper http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1977epfr.conf.1161Q http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1977epfr.conf.1161Q which uses "X-rays heat a working fluid in a boiler". The Rankine cycle thermodynamics prevent this from having an 80% efficiency. I used PV as an example because there's been a lot of work to make that efficient, and it's still only at 20% for commercially feasible cells. Did you notice that for 5MW of electrical power production they are generating 3MW of "losses"? That's about 1,000 tons of cooling (in the wonderful units of cooling. See http://www.trane.com/COMMERCIAL/DNA/View.aspx?i=978 http://www.trane.com/COMMERCIAL/DNA/View.aspx?i=978 ). If you air cool the system then you'll need a tower with dimensions about 14'x22'x19' ( http://www.trane.com/CPS/uploads/userfiles/chillers/coolingtowers/cool-slb002-en.pdf http://www.trane.com/CPS/uploads/userfiles/chillers/coolingt... ) "One TEU represents the cargo capacity of a standard intermodal container, 20 feet (6.1 m) long and 8 feet (2.44 m) wide.[1] There is a lack of standardisation in regards to height, ranging between 4 feet 3 inches (1.30 m) and 9 feet 6 inches (2.90 m), with the most common height being 8 feet 6 inches (2.59 m)." So just the cooling for this thing will be more than 1 shipping container in size. It certainly wouldn't fit in my (ex-) garage!
- DennisP 14y agoThat's pretty interesting on cooling. So, maybe gas station size after all. I suppose I can live with that :) I wouldn't think that comparing to the efficiency of other technologies is really that informative. The nearest thing I can think of to extracting energy from the beam is a linear alternator, which, if the comment here is correct: http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=254589 http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=254589 ...can have anywhere from 80% to 95% efficiency. I haven't found anything on the efficiency of photoelectric capture of x-rays, but from what I've seen Lerner seems to think that's the least of his worries. Perhaps he'll feel differently if he gets that far!
- dalke 14y agowww.sunpower.com/library/pdf/publications/Doc0064.pdf says 92%, and higher is possible with more cost. I really don't see how extracting energy from a charged particle beam can be compared to a linear alternator. The math is quite different. For example, you only extract energy from the front part of the beam, while in a linear alternator it slows down the entire piece of metal. This causes a problem because when you extract energy from the particles you slow them down. These are charged, so they will repel the particles coming in from behind. The better you are at extracting energy, the more the charged particles get in the way. The http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com page that you linked to, with the Sankey diagram, does itself a disservice by giving numbers accurate in some cases to 3 significant digits when the error bars are so high, or even unknown. An excess of detail, not based on experimental values, happens to be characteristic of the free energy/perpetual motion machine crowd. BTW, I misread that chart. It puts net energy at 24.7 kJ and losses at 42kJ, which means that 5 MW electrical production will generate 8.5 MW of heat. It'll need three times as much cooling as I thought it would. The predicted overall efficiency is about the same as other power plants.