3 ms·
By "smaller scale" I meant something smaller than a freighter. 5-20 MW is about what you would use for a freighter. A Liberty ship from WW2 generated 2MW of pow
by dalke 14y ago
By "smaller scale" I meant something smaller than a freighter. 5-20 MW is about what you would use for a freighter. A Liberty ship from WW2 generated 2MW of power.
I couldn't find the "complete power plant" you were talking about. 5 MW in a 0.5 TEU? That's 3m x 2.4m x 2.6m, which is rather small for a 5 MW plant. And rather large for something you want to drive about town in.
Especially since you still need to worry about cooling.
The closest numbers I could find was http://pesn.com/2011/01/12/9501741_Focus_Fusion_achieves_1-billion-degree_confinement/ http://pesn.com/2011/01/12/9501741_Focus_Fusion_achieves_1-b... which said:
> According to the interview I did with inventor Eric Lerner back in 2005, which was featured at Slashdot, this technology could give birth to a non-polluting power plant the size of a local gas station that would quietly and safely power 4,000 homes
A "local gas station" is much bigger than 0.5 TEU, and a highly vague definition. Assuming a home consumes 2kW then that's producing 8 MW.
Any plans I can find are highly speculative. Where is the published journal article you're talking about? The only ones I can find report experimental measurements of a non-power-producing setup. Any extrapolation from that to a real-world power plant is as highly suspect as "sequencing the human genome will cure cancer within 5 years."
Anyone who sold you plans for a working 5 MW focus fusion generator is almost certainly in the same class as selling you a perpetual motion machine. The best would be "in our optimistic future, we think this might be possible", and not a serious estimate that you could use for planning purposes.
- DennisP 14y agoYou can find the most recent focus fusion paper here: http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/index.php?option=com_lyftenbloggie&view=entry&year=2013&month=01&day=03&id=87%3A2012-end-of-year-report-&Itemid=90 http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/index.php?option=com_l... It was published in Physics of Plasmas last year and shows sufficient temperature (1.8 billion C) and confinement time for boron fusion, and also that the fusion is occurring in the confined plasmoid, not the beam, which is a necessary condition for this approach. The remaining hurdle is sufficient density. They think they can do it but we'll see. I was not claiming that a complete working design exists, which obviously is not the case since they haven't yet achieved net-positive fusion in the lab. Nobody has managed that yet, but focus fusion's ratio of neutron count to input power compares pretty favorably with other approaches so far. I don't think it's silly to make an informed speculation about what a power plant would look like, if the basic idea turned out to work. NIF for example has been doing a lot of that with their LIFE design, to the point of sourcing specific components. In the case of focus fusion, most of the power is released as a pulsed beam of charged particles. You can get energy from that by aiming it through a coil, no heat engine required. The rest of the energy goes into x-rays, which can be captured photoelectrically by a foil "onion" around the reactor core. You also need some good switches, a pretty substantial capacitor bank, and cooling. When I said "not Mr. Fusion" I was meaning to imply this would definitely not be something you drive around town in. Focus fusion certainly isn't something we can "plan" on, any more than a poker player can plan on winning a particular pot. But that doesn't mean it's not a worthwhile bet. The investment is low, the pot is really large, and the odds don't look that bad.
- dalke 14y agoThen I was lead astray by the comment about the engine being 1/2 the size of a shipping container. Where is the source of that speculation and how informed is it? How much energy can you get from a pulsed beam of charged particles? What's the efficiency level? The same question applies to getting power from X-rays. Photovoltaic is what, 20% at best? Certainly X-ray isn't that efficient. Which means 5 MW of electrical generation is going to require, what, 20 MW of input power? 500 MW? No matter what, it's going to require a lot of cooling. Enough that saying that it fits into a container doesn't make sense. And in any case, my statement was "We don't think it's possible to get fusion power to an even smaller scale [than a large ship's diesel engines]." You said "Some of the designs are pretty small-scale", but your example is already my example of a possible valid smaller scale. So I think this is a case of one of those arguments where we're both on the same side?
- DennisP 14y agoYes maybe we are :) Here's a diagram showing the energy flow they expect, if things work out: http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/index.php?option=com_lyftenbloggie&view=entry&year=2012&month=02&day=01&id=55%3Aunderstand-the-focus-fusion-energy-flow&Itemid=90 http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/index.php?option=com_l... Overall energy balance of focus fusion reactors would be somewhat marginal, nothing like the 100x to 1000x that Sandia's talking about for MagLIF. In this diagram they mention "garage-size." The "onion" is photoelectric, not photovoltaic.
- dalke 14y agoThe tricky point is the "80% energy efficiency recovery from the beam and X-ray pulse." That seems incredibly high, and it lacks any references. All I could find in my limited search was this paper http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1977epfr.conf.1161Q http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1977epfr.conf.1161Q which uses "X-rays heat a working fluid in a boiler". The Rankine cycle thermodynamics prevent this from having an 80% efficiency. I used PV as an example because there's been a lot of work to make that efficient, and it's still only at 20% for commercially feasible cells. Did you notice that for 5MW of electrical power production they are generating 3MW of "losses"? That's about 1,000 tons of cooling (in the wonderful units of cooling. See http://www.trane.com/COMMERCIAL/DNA/View.aspx?i=978 http://www.trane.com/COMMERCIAL/DNA/View.aspx?i=978 ). If you air cool the system then you'll need a tower with dimensions about 14'x22'x19' ( http://www.trane.com/CPS/uploads/userfiles/chillers/coolingtowers/cool-slb002-en.pdf http://www.trane.com/CPS/uploads/userfiles/chillers/coolingt... ) "One TEU represents the cargo capacity of a standard intermodal container, 20 feet (6.1 m) long and 8 feet (2.44 m) wide.[1] There is a lack of standardisation in regards to height, ranging between 4 feet 3 inches (1.30 m) and 9 feet 6 inches (2.90 m), with the most common height being 8 feet 6 inches (2.59 m)." So just the cooling for this thing will be more than 1 shipping container in size. It certainly wouldn't fit in my (ex-) garage!