3 ms·
I suspect you haven't worked out the feasibility of large-scale desalinization for food crops in the US. It doesn't seem economically reasonable, at least not u
by dalke 14y ago
I suspect you haven't worked out the feasibility of large-scale desalinization for food crops in the US. It doesn't seem economically reasonable, at least not until food is an order of magnitude more expensive than now.
We pull out ~30 cubic km of water from the Ogallala Aquifer per year. Let's estimate how much power is needed to replace this with seawater.
At 2780 J/liter, this requires about 3 gigawatts, assuming perfect efficiency. Realistically it's more like 15 GW. Okay, that's doable. The US generates about 1TW of electric power, so 1% would go to desalinization.
Next, you need to pump it to the midwest. The second Los Angeles Aqueduct cost $90 million in 1965 dollars to carry water 137 miles. That's about $500 million in 2013 dollars. The entire Aqueduct transports about 0.4 cubic kilometers of water per year. You'll need about 10x the length to get from the Gulf to the aquifer, and 8x the volume. You'll also need a distribution network, which is likely another 4x to the cost, and you'll need to pump it uphill, which means there's more expensive upkeep.
This sets a low estimate of 300*$5 billion = $1.50 trillion in construction costs, and that's deliberately low-balling the estimate. The Ogallala produces about $20 billion in agriculture each year. I don't think it's financially reasonable.
Also, where do you dump the brine with all of the salt that you've extracted? Back into the Gulf? That's going to seriously affect the marine life. Or do you fully dry out the salt and use it in place of salt mining? I calculate this as 1 gigaton of salt/year, or about 5x the current world production of salt.
Even with free power, it doesn't seem that desalinization could replace the supply that we currently get from the Ogallala Aquifer. At least, not without having much higher food prices.
Instead, you'll have to relocate farming to some place closer to the sea which is also water restricted. In the US, this is ... where? More of the Central Valley? Where is the Nebraska-sized chunk of land by the coast that lacks only water in order to flourish?
Or we import more food from Australia, which seems the prime candidate for this approach.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoHave you considered the ramifications of moving where farming is possible? The combination of desalinization and the ability to make long chain hydrocarbons (like fertilizer) means you can farm the San Fernando valley with seawater and take a tremendous load off of the California aqueduct system. Places in Mexico become targets for new farms. All freshwater in the southeastern part of Texas can come from the Gulf of Mexico. It is an interest experiment to look at a map of coastal areas with arid or desert climates, and think about those becoming farmland. The brine issue is non-existent, as both Qatar and Saudi Arabia have demonstrated with their desalination plants you can pump a lot of sea water through them with the output water having only slightly more salinity than the input water. That and the fact that fusion power is initially additive to the total power output rather than replacement power. The challenge is of course the numbers. The original Nuclear energy projection of power 'too cheap to measure' was based on an assumption that once nuclear power regulatory structures were in place, the cost to build a plant would converge to something close to the capital costs. That assumption turned out to be false. If it turns out to be false for fusion as well then we'll have different effects.
- dalke 14y ago"like fertilizer" - fertilizer by definition contains elements besides hydrogen, carbons, and oxygens. It is not a "long chain hydrocarbon." The brine issue is not non-existent. http://www.thenational.ae/news/uae-news/environment/desalination-threat-to-the-growing-gulf http://www.thenational.ae/news/uae-news/environment/desalina... "Between the tankers, pollution from urban centres and the brine disposed from desalination plants, the Gulf is almost dead." Well, I guess if it's almost dead then the effect of the brine has a less overall impact. What would the effect be on the shrimp industry in the Gulf? Saudi Arabia produces 450 million liters per day. That's 5.2 m3/second or 0.16 cubic kilometers/year, or about 1/20th what the Ogallala Aquifer provides. I found that Qatar produces 1.5 million m3/day = 17 m3/second. http://www.cvwd.org/about/agricultural.php http://www.cvwd.org/about/agricultural.php says that the "Coachella Valley Water District delivers 280,000 acre-feet annually ... to irrigate nearly 60,000 acres of farmland." That's 11 m3/second on average, so about the same order of magnitude. Also, "Overall crop production exceeds half a billion dollars a year." By comparison, Israel has about 460,000 acres of farmland and California has 9 million acres of irrigated land. Now, how much will the infrastructure cost to build the desalination plants, and the canals, and the pumps needed to make the entire system work against gravity? Even if you assume the power cost is free, there's a lot of maintenance overhead, and the system is more fragile then a gravity fed aqueduct. I'm definitely not saying that it isn't possible. I pointed out that Australia would be an excellent place for this. That's why I said that it wouldn't be that useful in the US. While you're correct about Texas, that's still only a small percentage of the US farmland, and Texas doesn't have the same weather that makes California so successful. But using desalinated water for irrigation isn't free/cheap by far, and the cost of power is not the only constraint in making it successful. Any analysis which doesn't include the costs of moving water uphill and delivering it is necessarily incomplete and inadequate.
- ChuckMcM 14y ago'fertilizer' -> Ammonium Nitrate - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonium_nitrate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonium_nitrate (NH4NO3) Nothing more than air (using the Nitrogen) and Water normally the Haber-Bosch process used natural gas as its source of H2 however it is also easily produced by splitting water if the energy is "free".
- Retric 14y agoYour math is way off somewhere. 1960 to 2004 dollars : 650 million X10 for 10x length 6.5 billion X8 for 8x volume (pipes are not 2x cost for 2x volume but letes assume 8 pipes for redundancy): 52 billion. X4 for distribution 208 billion. Though, as you could just pump it back in the aquifer. And you don't needed redundancy if a the aquifer can provide plenty of buffer so 3x for volume 1.2x for pumping and 1.1 x for distribution is probably a better estimate. = ~25 billion. Assuming you can get the billing down. As for farming elseware AZ, Texas, etc could grow a lot more crops with a little more irrigation, so could northern Africa and most of Mexico.
- dalke 14y agoD'oh! I copied a "$500 million" as "$5 billion". That's the power of 10 error. Also, I used 1970 dollars since the source I gave said "started in 1965", "took 5 years", "cost $90 million." There's why you have the $650 instead of my $500. Last time I looked, aquifer recharge was not a simple topic. If the ground has already settled then there isn't as much storage space. I also think you have to pump in from many different places, so there's still the distribution network. You can't fill it up in North Dakota and think of being able to fill up Nebraska as well. My main point was to show that "Fresh water no longer becomes an issue because arbitrary amounts of sea water can be converted into fresh water." is not a true statement. Even with free power it's still expensive to bring that fresh water to Nebraska. As I recall, Texas isn't as good a place as California. In "Cadillac Desert", the author, Marc Reisner, points out how the lack of rain in summer means that farmers in California can give exactly as much water as is needed to induce the crops to grow better. ("Better" in a production sense, of course.) While in Texas, the intermittent rains and occasional downpours would not make that possible. I don't think that an irrigated Texas would have the same productivity as the Central Valley. But I don't know it that means 5% less or 50% less. Otherwise, yes, I agree that Texas is the best place to take advantage of cheap desalinated water in the US.