3 ms·
No one can answer that question without knowing what "perfected" looks like. A Back to the Future-style Mr. Fusion, which can produce 1.21 GW in a volume the si
by dalke 14y ago
No one can answer that question without knowing what "perfected" looks like. A Back to the Future-style Mr. Fusion, which can produce 1.21 GW in a volume the size of a household coffee grinder, is quite different than a large plant which produces the same.
The large power plants based on oil, coal, natural gas, nuclear, etc. are thermal power stations. They use heat to convert liquid water into steam, which then drives steam turbines. These necessarily (by the laws of thermodynamics) produce a lot of waste heat. More than half of the energy used to heat the water is not turned into power at the end.
The waste heat is dumped in the large condensers of the cooling towers, which often have the characteristic hyperboloid shape because it's the most efficient form. This requires a lot of space.
So a commercial fusion system for large-scale use, if it can be built, would likely be little different than a nuclear power plant now, because it requires a big steam turbine at a large facility.
On a smaller scale, you might replace a large ship's diesel engines with electrically-driven fusion powered systems. This would reduce ship pollution and reduce the number of times it needs to refuel. (Assuming that a perfected system needs little maintenance otherwise.)
We don't think it's possible to get fusion power to an even smaller scale, other than people whose proposals and work are difficult to distinguish from a perpetual motion machine scams.
If we did have Mr. Fusion, then it would be a game changer. We would be able to have airplanes and helicopters driven by electric motors, powered by Mr. Fusion. You could probably think about the other things possible of power were essentially free. What about heaters under the sidewalks to melt the ice? I loved going to the outdoor heated pools in Iceland, heated by cheap geothermal. With free power, we would see more outdoor pools elsewhere. More people would have hothouses for growing flowers and plants in winter. Canada could become a major producer of orchids. People in Haiti wouldn't have to strip their country of trees in order to get power. And so on.
Mr. Fusion isn't going to happen, at least not soon. We'll still need transmission lines. This sets a lower limit on the cost of power. Life would be like in Iceland or the Pacific NW, where power is cheap enough that aluminum smelters relocated there for access to cheap power, or where data centers get located in the Dells for cheap power and cooling for data centers. (And where farmers use the cheap power for moving water around.)
In other words, not much different than it is now. Except with less dependency on petroleum sources and the global politics that that entails.
- cstross 14y agoMr Fusion isn't going to go on board airliners any time soon if Mr Fusion is running on a De/T cycle reaction -- did you notice the He + n side of the equation? Fusion neutrons are not your friend, and a good chunk of the 'magic' of a working fusion reactor is going to lie in how it takes those neutral, uncharged, go-through-lead-like-it's-barely-there neutrons and turns them into heat (and thus electricity).
- jlgreco 14y agoAre the neutrons that fusion kicks off particularly more difficult to deal with than those kicked off by fission?
- dalke 14y agoMr. Fusion doesn't run on a De/T cycle. It can use a banana peel, beer, and the beer can itself as fuel. No, it makes no physical sense. Perhaps it's a branding name, since "Mr. Zero Point Energy" doesn't flow as well.
- nexox 14y agoNote: Lead (and dense materials in general) are not known for their abilities to absorb or slow neutrons - typically shielding is composed of materials composed of a high proportion of light hydrogen atoms, such as water, wax, or plastic.
- russell 14y agoIIRC, trapping the neutrons in water or some similar compound is how the power is extracted from a D-T reaction. However, my ignorance exceeds my curiosity.
- DennisP 14y agoSome of the designs are pretty small-scale, though not Mr. Fusion size. The smallest is focus fusion. The reactor core is the size of a coffee can, and the complete power plant would be about half the size of a shipping container, and produce 5 to 20 MW. Since it would use (mostly) aneutronic boron fusion you could safely locate them near their customers, and remove most of the transmission cost. They've published a couple papers recently in respectable journals so I think they're easily distinguished from perpetual motion.