2 ms·
I think this is basically true. But a point worth making is that a "puzzle" problem is a much heavier thing than lightweight tests like FizzBuzz. If you hand
by ajross 14y ago
I think this is basically true. But a point worth making is that a "puzzle" problem is a much heavier thing than lightweight tests like FizzBuzz. If you hand someone a puzzle you're pretty much guaranteed (absent the rare, truly gifted candidate) to watch them struggle at a whiteboard for half an hour. FizzBuzz (or "reverse words in a sentence", or whatever) will tell you the same thing in a minute or two.
Basically, the Venn diagram regions for "can code fluently" and "can solve puzzles" have a ton of overlap. So test the first one, not the second.
- hackinthebochs 14y agoYou make a good point. The question is how much of an overlap is there? Is there value in adding a component of raw intelligence to the question (say, applying a data structure in a unique and non-obvious way)? It is reasonable to expect that the act of programming fluently entails a sufficient level of IQ such that there is nothing more to be learned from attempting to craft a question that tests intelligence directly? Two bits of information could potentially answer this: does intelligence as a predictor of future job success drop off past a certain level? Also, what does the distribution of IQ look like for those who are fluent coders?