7 ms·
I don't know if this is a Silicon Valley thing or what, but the idea that someone would basically do a day's unpaid work on projects they know nothing about wit
by pc86 14y ago
I don't know if this is a Silicon Valley thing or what, but the idea that someone would basically do a day's unpaid work on projects they know nothing about with three different people is just about the most foreign thing I can think of.
That being said, I've never done any pairing so maybe it would work better in that type of environment.
- ben1040 14y ago>I don't know if this is a Silicon Valley thing or what, but the idea that someone would basically do a day's unpaid work on projects they know nothing about with three different people is just about the most foreign thing I can think of. Yep. That basically amounts to an application fee.
- jasonshen 14y agoIf you think it costs you something to be interviewed (thus your suggestion about an application fee) it certainly costs the company at least that much if not more. They are paying their staff to work with you on something that likely will not produce direct value for the company (usually a throwaway project or trivial task) Plus they will spend time before and after the interview discussing your qualifications, performance etc. It comes out about even.
- rboyd 14y agoBy this logic the candidate should pay half of travel and hotel too.
- nitrogen 14y agoUsually the candidate pays all of it.
- saryant 14y agoReally? Of the three job interviews I've traveled for in the last year, all were paid by the company 100%.
- nickbarnwell 14y agoSeconding this; even for internships I've not once paid for travel costs. Everyone from small, YC startups up to MS/Google paid for cab fare, flights, and hotels.
- doktrin 14y agoThis is highly unusual (if not unheard of). A company would have to be pretty damn unique in order to justify having candidates pay for their own travel + lodging.
- nitrogen 14y agoMost jobs are not provided by SV companies or Microsoft. Most prople are not in a career that typically hires from across the country at their own expense. Paid travel is a luxury enjoyed by a small segment of job candidates.
- doktrin 14y agoExpanding the scope of discussion to all jobs is disingenuous. It's pretty clear this thread (not to mention this forum) is fairly software centric. Regardless, companies across just about all industries that hire from remote talent pools will pay for travel (consulting, finance, government, NGOs, banking, accounting, manufacturing, insurance, you-name-it). Whether or not a given company expands its talent search to include workers in distant locations is bound by several factors, none of which are unique to "SV and Microsoft".
- dyno12345 14y agoThe candidate is taking a much bigger risk. If the job doesn't work out, they lose small% of potential productivity, while you will lose 100% of your income. Companies have numerous employees, but you only have one employer. You bet everything on your employer, they only bet a small part of their hand on you.
- pi18n 14y agoThe company is expected to have costs when hiring, it isn't appropriate to push them onto the applicants by having them work it off. What if a company gave you an itemized bill after your interview? You're still exchanging something of value for their time; is that reasonable or ridiculous?
- walshemj 14y agoWhich is strictly forbidden in most jurisdictions.
- einhverfr 14y agoIt depends on how it is structured. I doubt there would be anything wrong with saying "we maintain open source project X and we only hire people who have made submissions in this project that we have accepted. If you want to be considered for employment, you must first get involved in the community."
- mleach 14y agoThere is more "soft skill" assessment going on with pair programming than "hard skills".
- pseut 14y agoA job interview is going to take at least a day of your time anyway. What does it matter if that time is spent programming, talking over coffee, sketching on a whiteboard, or whatever?
- ebiester 14y agoMany interviews I've had are 2 hour affairs, including jobs I've received where interviews were 45 minutes.
- pseut 14y agoI guess it depends on the position, but the point still stands. Given that you spend x amount of time interviewing, what does it matter how it's spent? (with the obvious caveats that if they spend, say, 3 hours screaming at you as a stress test, you probably don't want to work there, etc etc).
- brown9-2 14y agoWell with a "regular" interview, it's pretty unlikely that the company is going to make any money off of the direct output of the interview. When helping them develop a feature or product, it's slightly different.
- pseut 14y agoAnd...? I'm in academia. I've had job interviews where I've literally gone office to office discussing people's research projects and helping them come up with ideas. It was fun, and it never occurred to me that I was being taken advantage of. Worst case scenario, they might think of me as a potential consultant down the line.
- ry0ohki 14y agoPretend it's not tech, and Starbucks interview consisted of you working as a barista for a day, or Goldman Sachs wanted you to trade stocks for a day, etc...
- hexagonc 14y agoI doubt that work important to the company is done this way. Otherwise, they'd expose proprietary information. Of course, I could be wrong.
- jasonlotito 14y agoSpending a day doing useless work is worse.
- lucian303 14y agoCoding exercises (before even going in for an interview) waste an engineer's valuable time and in some cases a deceitful way for a company to solve problems it can't on its own. Asking people to work for free is ridiculous.