5 ms·
This is something to think about. The interview process is so badly gamed that these days its kind of a ceremony. In a recent interview, I gave a candidate a p
by kamaal 14y ago
This is something to think about.
The interview process is so badly gamed that these days its kind of a ceremony. In a recent interview, I gave a candidate a practical problem. He was allowed to use the sed man page, and then I gave him a file and search/replace problem. Nothing much! The candidate fails! Instead he asks me if there is going to be a algorithm/data structure interview. I told him, I don't know but as far as I was concerned I was only going to test him on practical everyday problems.
It was almost like I had committed a sin. He was like, every company has those standard one's so why was I doing like a practical test. These days all candidates do is go through most common puzzles/algorithms/data structure stuff. Its actually quite easy to get access to those. Just spend some time on interview forums and you can practically game any interview, in any company any where around the world today.
My approach is straight simple. Throw a manual/documentation at the person. Give him a problem common enough to test a practical everyday situation. Check if he can pass the the test of reading the documentation and figuring out the solution to the problem. Or give him/her their favorite IDE/text editor + documentation + problem and let them solve it.
If they can do it, or even get the approach right they pass the test.
Else if all they are going to do is vomit some mathematical theory from college text books, which isn't even remotely relevant to our everyday work- I'm hardly interested in hiring such candidates.
- mamcx 14y agoI do something like that. My first test is ask to reverse a string (not using the reverse function!) in any language and/or pseudocode. Is incredible how badly the test goes with the people! I interview for myself or others more than 100 people (of any background, including university, tech schols...) and I think only 10/12 people do it correctly - barely- To make it more fair, I always let them alone. And give internet and a computer, and remember them they can use internet and search. Not even with that amount of help the thing work well (I truly have find someone smart enough to copy-paste something and return to me in 1 minute or less). Then i do the puzzle question, but know I retire it some years ago and some more question about real stuff...
- biscarch 14y agoThis is great. My first thought was "perfect, Haskell!" reverse "whatever" "No reverse function? but we can use the internet? The Prelude source probably has the best implementation of a reverse." foldl (flip (:)) [] "whatever"
- doktrin 14y agoReversing a string is actually an incredibly common interview question. It's a bit like FizzBuzz (IME even more common, but I can't really speak about the world at large).
- mmorett 14y agoIt might be an incredibly common interview question, but it's not an incredibly common day-to-day task, particularly when there are methods built in to classes that perform this function. An interesting task? Perhaps. But not reflection of the dev's skills, per se. You're not asking about syntax with this. It's a problem solving question and at the end of the day, the only real metric here is not whether a dev could code this up, but whether he can code it up quickly, under time constraints, while being stared at, under pressure, with rent or a mortgage on the line, and maybe kids to feed. I am hard pressed to think of even one real life dev task I had in my entire career where I had to solve a problem under those circumstances. For most devs, we take ownership of the problem and solve it at our desk under reasonable time frames without the spotlight. For bigger problems, we might think about it in the car on the way home. We might sleep on it over the weekend. That doesn't apply to reversing a string, of course. But you have to consider that, depending on the dev's background and skills, he may be spending time in jQuery, maybe Spring and Hibernate (for Java guys), maybe even some CSS. Maybe he's a GWT guy? Maybe he was assigned to a team dedicated to (God forbid) EJBs. In other words, he may be multifaceted and spends more time working with an API than "just" raw language coding. The language is just a means for working with the API. And the one thing you want to measure is not something he does daily. Now, if he can't use a for loop, feel free to mock him. But reversing a string? That's clearly a puzzle. EDIT: I can't get this part out of my mind: "Is incredible how badly the test goes with the people! I interview for myself or others more than 100 people (of any background, including university, tech schols...) and I think only 10/12 people do it correctly - barely-" So you continue to use that question? Despite the results? So that when you do hire a guy that passes, he won't ever do this on the job because you know you damn well he should use the reverse() method? Because you won't pay him to code it raw and waste time and money when there is a 1.5 second solution to this? That's sadistic. :-)
- jnbiche 14y agoMay I ask where you work? I'd love to interview at a company like yours. I'm in the process of changing careers to programming in my late 30s. I dabbled in coding on and off for most of my life, but two years ago I started taking it seriously, read K&R, etc, and completely fell in love with programming. And so I start thinking about working full-time as a developer, and schedule an interview for a programming position for a company in the industry where I've worked for the past decade. I've always been a confident interviewer, but I totally froze in this phone interview. They started the interview off with a tough algorithm problem that I probably could have solved on my own in 30-40 minutes, but couldn't possibly solve on the spot in a conference call, with several people listening in and quizzing me. From there, things went downhill quickly, and I struggled to answer questions that I could have easily answered on my own at my desk. Since then, I've been burned on two freelance programming assignments (that I should have known better than to take given the level of desperation involved), which was quite a blow after spending a decade freelancing for dozens of clients without incident in another industry. I love programming, and so I continue to code whenever I get the chance (and have two rather large projects underway), but these experiences have shaken my confidence. If most programming jobs involve similar interview processes, I'm not sure this would be the best move for me. However, this comment has given me hope. If there are companies out there like this, then I stand a fighting chance -- I would excel at an interview where I'm given a problem, a time limit, vim, and then told to go solve it with no whiteboard or group of people watching. Let it be a hard problem, but make it realistic -- not some obscure puzzle or algorithm -- and let me use my own tools. I wish there were some job board where companies with this type of interview process posted jobs.
- biscarch 14y agoSeconded. I'll even spend the extra time on it if we can do something similar to "Here is the problem and the docs. Email me back within the hour with some working code and we'll get on a call to talk through your thought process". It's like trying to run a competitive 100m without shoes at some interviews I've been through lately.