5 ms·
One of the major issues in this debate is the disconnect in how things like CRA are perceived, and how they are implemented. If you check the CRA what you will
by bilbo0s 18y ago
One of the major issues in this debate is the disconnect in how things like CRA are perceived, and how they are implemented.
If you check the CRA what you will discover is that it is intended to increase lending in 'disadvantaged communities'. That's right, the loans are based on neighborhood, not individual disadvantages. For instance, an impoverished person from inner city Chicago finds a great deal on a house in Evanston, a suburb. CRA does NOT cover this situation, as you imply, because Evanston is not a 'disadvantaged community'. Same guy wants to buy a house in inner city Chicago and CRA DOES cover his situation.
That's where the fun starts!
It's at that point that people like me were helping large development firms come in and buy up property in the 'disadvantaged communities'. You keep just enough poor people to keep the disadvantaged designation and you build condos that sell like hot cakes. Usually you set aside a few units in every building for 'disadvantaged' people to buy. But here's the beauty of it. Most municipalities classify 'economically disadvantaged' as 'at or below the median income' for that municipality.
By way of example, in Madison, WI, at the time, I believe it was $50000 per year that made you 'economically disadvantaged'. Make below $50000 per year, and you would qualify for one of the set aside units. The developer still made a killing, the cities looked like they were helping regular folks, and crime in the downtown areas dropped dramatically.
Of course, now we see the mortgage crisis and the unintended consequences, but it all seemed like a good idea at the time. And parts of it were a good idea.
Now, I don't know who explained CRA to you. But I can tell you unequivocally that for developers tools like this were VITAL. TIF as well. Downtown redevelopment rarely works without them.
IF it is the case that politicians wanted to help these people, then they should have written the law so that it centered on the people and not the neighborhoods. My own opinion is that the real estate development industry probably lobbied hard to have CRA center on the idea of disadvantaged neighborhood. Because the whole thing was just too easy to not have been planned.
In summary, take my word for it, I am VERY well versed with urban real estate development. CRA was not, indeed cannot, be used in the fashion you intimate. If someone told you that CRA obliged a bank to loan to people who could not afford it, then I'm afraid you've been misinformed. CRA obliges banks to lend in NEIGHBORHOODS that are disadvantaged.
It is not by accident that many luxury condo developments are in formerly sketch areas. Nor is it a happenstance that the 'downtown condo' rose to prominence with the expansion of CRA. Go to any major city in the US and find a long time resident to walk around downtown with you. The story s/he will tell you will go something like this:
"Boy, I can remember when this was a really dangerous area. But they really have fixed it up haven't they! When my kid goes off to college, we're thinking of moving down here!"
And finally, as always, don't take my word for it. That was your mistake before, when you took the word of someone else that CRA obliged banks to lend to people who could not afford it. What I would encourage you to do is read through the act your self. Start here, http://www.ffiec.gov/cra/ http://www.ffiec.gov/cra/. You will see that 'communities' and 'neighborhoods' are the units of interest.
Always get the data on your own kid. There are a lot of people out there trying to manipulate right now. Left wing socialists, right wing corporatists. Trust no one! Go read it for yourself.
- defen 18y agoThe problem with CRA is not that it "obliges" banks to lend to people who can't afford it. The problem is that if you don't lend enough money to minorities (who disproportionately can't afford it), the federal bank regulators can block you from acquiring/being acquired by other banks. For data on default rates see http://www.huduser.org/publications/affhsg/FHASingleFamily.html http://www.huduser.org/publications/affhsg/FHASingleFamily.h... For data on CRA dollars committed see http://www.community-wealth.org/_pdfs/articles-publications/cdfis/report-ncrc.pdf http://www.community-wealth.org/_pdfs/articles-publications/... (4.2 TRILLION between '92 and '05)
- bilbo0s 18y agoAgain, CRA is centered around the concept of NEIGHBORHOOD investment. Not investment in minorities. When you say: <<"The problem is that if you don't lend enough money to minorities (who disproportionately can't afford it), the federal bank regulators can block you from acquiring/being acquired by other banks.">> I'm confused as to which part of the act you are speaking about. Perhaps you could post the link to the relevant statute, and we can discuss this based on the data. Regarding the links you provided, again, what is the relative default rate? This is the key piece of data we need. Even better, would be the absolute amounts of money that were defaulted on. That said, I would observe that it is interesting, wouldn't you say, that default rates on FHA HUD loans should be so public, and default rates on the Fannie and Freddy backed stuff so closed. Even more interesting that, as I said in response to your other post, Ginnie Mae should still be solvent considering Fannie and Freddy are basket cases. Finally, I am uncertain as to how the links you provided support the assertion that CRA precludes banks who don't lend to minorities from acquiring or being acquired. If you would elaborate on the connection I could determine better whether or not I agree with you.
- defen 18y agoHave you actually read the CRA? I guess I'll spell it out for you. From the NCRC pdf linked above, "Since the passage of CRA in 1977, lenders and community organizations have signed over 428 CRA agreements totaling more than $4.2 trillion in reinvestment dollars flowing to minority and lower income neighborhoods." From the CRA (http://www.fdic.gov/regulations/laws/rules/6500-2515.html http://www.fdic.gov/regulations/laws/rules/6500-2515.html) 802.a.1 - `"regulated financial institutions are required by law to demonstrate that their deposit facilities serve the convenience and needs of the communities in which they are chartered to do business;"` 803.3 - `the term "application for a deposit facility" means an application to the appropriate Federal financial supervisory agency otherwise required under Federal law or regulations thereunder for--` 803.3.E `the merger or consolidation with, or the acquisition of the assets, or the assumption of the liabilities of a regulated financial institution requiring approval` 804.a `SEC. 804. (a) IN GENERAL.--In connection with its examination of a financial institution, the appropriate Federal financial supervisory agency shall-- (1) assess the institution's record of meeting the credit needs of its entire community, including low- and moderate-income neighborhoods, consistent with the safe and sound operation of such institution; and (2) take such record into account in its evaluation of an application for a deposit facility by such institution.` See also this WSJ article (entered into the Senate record) http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/R?r106:FLD001:S05028 http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/R?r106:FLD001:S05028 "Last week the Senate passed a bill over-hauling the regulation of banks, including a provision sponsored by Sen. Phil Gramm (R., Texas), chairman of the Banking Committee, to reform the Community Reinvestment Act. Mr. Gramm's provision has stirred controversy, to say the least. Last month hundreds of ``community activists'' descended on his house, where they pounded on the windows, trampled the landscaping and left the yard covered with garbage." "The 20-year-old CRA requires banks to serve their entire community. Regulators take banks' CRA compliance into account when deciding whether to approve applications for mergers or expanded services. In the recent wave of bank consolidation, banks have made billions of dollars of loan commitments and signed agreements with numerous community organizations in order to be seen as complying with CRA."