2 ms·
> How about have less government, no corporate lobbying and no corporatism? A large, powerful government is eventually taken over by corporate interests, and b
by lutusp 14y ago
> How about have less government, no corporate lobbying and no corporatism?
A large, powerful government is eventually taken over by corporate interests, and becomes an active enabler of corporate goals.
A small, conservative government of the sort idealized by libertarians is too small and powerless to influence corporations, which respond by taking hold of the reins of public power, as was true in the early days of industrialization.
Believe me, I'm not advocating some alternative like Communism, which history teaches is manifestly worse than the two alternatives listed above.
I think modern corporations are an unavoidable side effect of the evolution of modern societies -- highly organized, wired, and with a natural tendency to concentrate power in a few hands. All that remains is to see which hands get the power.
- gadders 14y agoWhy should governments influence corporations?
- lutusp 14y ago"In the public interest". I'm not advocating it, just saying what the stock explanation is. But I can think of examples that support governmental intervention. The Thalidomide story, in which a greedy drug company pressed for the right to sell a drug in the U.S. but was stonewalled by one stubborn government official. Eventually the drug was shown to create horrible birth defects in countries where it was allowed to be sold. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide#Birth_defects_crisis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide#Birth_defects_crisi... I'm sure there are many more examples. I'm also sure that no one will be able to write a perfectly objective assessment of the benefits and drawbacks to governmental intervention in the affairs of business.
- nickik 14y agoSelection bias. The goverments regulation also blocks many diffrent medications for a long time that kill lots of people because they could not be sold. Also there is the case where drugs got banned because the had bad effects on some people in some conditions, but was still fine for other people again kill or making many people worse off. All in all goverment regulation of medicine has been horrible. Let people (adived by doctors and other organisations) decide with drugs they want. Here is a nice interview with Marcia Angell of Harvard Medical School about big farma. > http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/11/angell_on_big_p.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/11/angell_on_big_p.htm... I would also throw away IP but that another discussion.
- lutusp 14y ago> Selection bias. What? I said "I can think of examples that support governmental intervention." I did not say "I have statistically analyzed governmental interventions and here are my results." > The goverments [sic] regulation also blocks ... Do you really not know how to spell "government"? So it seems: > All in all goverment [sic] regulation of medicine has been horrible. You're the one making unsupportable general claims, not me. Also, given that yours is a post about government, learn how to spell "government". > Here is a nice interview with Marcia Angell of Harvard Medical School about big farma [sic]. Do you by chance mean "big pharma"?
- nickik 14y ago> You're the one making unsupportable general claims, not me. Look at the reaseach on the workings of the FDA. Seams to me that most people agree on its bad performance.