3 ms·
I spent some time at Reddit in years past, in fact I did two AMAs myself. I think I know the reason for the discrepancy between the votes and the comments. One
by lutusp 14y ago
I spent some time at Reddit in years past, in fact I did two AMAs myself. I think I know the reason for the discrepancy between the votes and the comments.
One, people who post comments belong to a different demographic than those who simply vote -- the difference is in the level of effort, the level of aggressiveness and the willingness to get involved in a subsequent conversation. I think there's a gender difference (women are more likely to vote without commenting, men more likely to comment and not vote) -- bu I emphasize that, with regard to HN, this is a supposition with some observational evidence, but not a solid statistic.
Two, as to AMA threads themselves, when I was the subject of an AMA, the voting and commenting patterns were completely different than an ordinary conversation. After my second AMA with the same result, I finally figured it out -- many of those who posted questions and comments in AMA forums were women interested in meeting someone noteworthy, and who commented and voted in a way that set them apart from other kinds of forums. At Reddit there really is a large difference between the population of commenters at AMA events versus ordinary conversations, and the primary difference is gender.
For those who think this gender distinction is just my overactive imagination, read this AMA forum and judge for yourself:
http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/q9qzn/iama_former_nasa_space_shuttle_engineer_created/ http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/q9qzn/iama_former_nasa...
What this would mean at HN is that an AMA would very likely be very different than one at Reddit, because there are fewer women who post here regularly compared to Reddit. That's too bad, but I am only reporting a fact.
I think if you compare silent votes versus comments anywhere, you will see a difference in views, not all of it is based on gender, but gender is a factor -- many women are more willing to cast a silent vote than post a comment and risk a hostile reply from someone accustomed to talking to men. Note that I didn't say "all women" and I don't know the reasons or how important the difference is, either quantitatively or qualitatively. But it is certainly real.