2 ms·
I am also wary of people suggesting that software whose users are "required" to pay a per-user fee could be open source. Open source software could not come wit
by schoen 14y ago
I am also wary of people suggesting that software whose users are "required" to pay a per-user fee could be open source. Open source software could not come with a universally enforceable requirement of this kind. "The license may not restrict any party from selling or giving away the software..."
But the prospect of open source developers being paid other than per-copy, per-user is plausible. Alex Tabarrok demonstrated in 1996 that it should be possible to do it even without altruism given enforcement of contracts and someone with sufficient information about demand. (I don't know if that kind of information is often achieved in practice.)
Karl Fogel just ran a successful Kickstarter campaign to fund creation of the second edition of Producing Open Source Software, which will be distributed on terms closely parallel to open source software (all recipients of the book can redistribute and modify it, and nobody is required to pay a per-copy license fee). The payment to Karl happened up front and ahead of time. The same structure might have worked if Karl were to apply this funding to software development instead of to writing about software development -- and indeed Joey Hess did that a while ago with his git-annex-assistant Kickstarter, which as far as I know has worked out quite well.
In the Kickstarter case there is a significant potential free-rider problem; for example, I didn't personally fund Joey's project but I might still benefit from his work on git-annex. Kickstarter seems to use various aspects of social norms and psychology to address free riding, often with good results.
I think we need more work on this even as we continue to insist on not diluting the meaning of open source.
- btilly 14y agoThere are lots of models for how open source developers can be paid. The first person that I am aware of to be hired exclusively to develop open source software (though he of course called it free software) was Brian Fox in 1985. The first company that I am aware of to establish a successful commercial business exclusively around open source software (though of course again it was called free software) was Cygnus in 1989. The business model is that people developing new chips needed a compiler for their chip, and would hire Cygnus on a contract to port GCC for them. (The resulting port then got folded back into GCC.) There are thousands of people today whose paid job is developing open source software. Are there more people who want this type of work who don't get it? Absolutely. Are there a lot of useful projects that don't get funded? Of course. But there are a lot of these projects out there.