2 ms·
I'm not sure a poll like this is an adequate sample to draw any conclusions from. Regardless of what the HN community at large would prefer as the result of tha
by eridius 14y ago
I'm not sure a poll like this is an adequate sample to draw any conclusions from. Regardless of what the HN community at large would prefer as the result of that poll, it doesn't surprise me in the least that the people who are afraid of change, and thus have the most to lose if the Yessers win, are those who speak up. They already feel invested in the current way HN works, and so they're willing to spend the extra bit of effort to try to preserve that. However, people who would like to see reddit-style AMA aren't as invested in that idea, as it's a new one for HN, and thus have less incentive to spend the extra effort and comment about it.
- afhof 14y agoI think you are begging the question here: there is an unstated assumption by your use of the word "sample" that everyone's opinion has equivalent weight as everyone else's. Suppose that each persons vote didn't count for just +1 to any option, but rather added their total karma to an option. Would yes still have won?
- PakG1 14y agoWhat I would be interested in is a demographic analysis of who made comments. 1. Whether the comments are mostly made by people who are frequently adding to discussions. 2. Whether the comments are mostly made by people who have a high level of karma. Likewise analyses for the votes. OP makes a lot of assumptions that these analyses would answer.
- eridius 14y agoThat's not what begging the question means.