3 ms·
>A vastly more effective approach would be to encourage and cheer those trying to wean America from its addiction to automobiles.... While that's true, it's al
by jseliger 14y ago
>A vastly more effective approach would be to encourage and cheer those trying to wean America from its addiction to automobiles....
While that's true, it's also not happening: the only real way it might is through considerably higher density (which I support, both through the removal of urban height limits and mandatory lot setbacks), but across the world density has actually been declining for decades, as Shlomo Angel shows in Planet of Cities:
New empirical evidence on the average population density of cities across space and time confirms that these densities have been in decline almost everywhere for a century or more. The new evidence is counterintuitive, since numerous academic researchers believe that urban densities have been on the increase. Were that true, it would lend encouragement and support to those favoring densification. However, urban density decline has been persistent and global in scope, and it predated the automobile. It is not restricted to the United States or other industrialized countries, but is pervasive in developing countries as well. [. . .]
You should support greater density, bike lines, etc., but in reality we're going to be relying on car-based transportation for the foreseeable future—which means decades at the very least.
Again, I would like to see more cities that allow and encourage non-car transport, but I haven't seen much of it, and current property law prevents people from actually building those kinds of cities.
- snogglethorpe 14y ago> in reality we're going to be relying on car-based transportation for the foreseeable future—which means decades at the very least. Well, maybe you (and much of the U.S.) will be. Not me or my friends in Europe, China, etc, though.... Anyway, the fact that there's a long way to go (in many places) makes it all the more important to push hard, and soon. Part of the issue is that even though many countries haven't sunk to a level quite as low as the U.S., they still ironically look to the U.S. as an example, so when the U.S. does something bad, the effect is magnified. ... and yeah, getting rid of idiotic zoning laws is an important part of the solution.
- SeanLuke 14y ago> Well, maybe you (and much of the U.S.) will be. Not me or my friends in Europe, China, etc, though.... Fun fact. Italy has a very extensive non-car infrastucture, particularly trains. Yet I have dozens of friends and relatives in Milan, Rome, Rimini, and the countryside of Emilia-Romagna. Every single one of them has a car, sometimes two. The same goes for Northern Ireland.
- snogglethorpe 14y agoOf course, some people owning cars is not the same as society "relying on car-based transportation" (as the grandparent said). Tokyo has probably the best public transport system in the world, and automobiles have a ridiculously low mode-share for a modern city (12%), but car ownership rates are, relatively, much higher (approx. 300 cars/1000 people). Many people own cars that they use "occasionally," when it makes sense, not as their primary means of transportation. If those people all suddenly lost use of their cars, what would happen? Not much really; the city could cope easily.