12 ms·
Why Should Taxpayers Give Big Banks $83 Billion a Year?
- DamnYuppie 14y agoWe will be better served as a nation with smaller banks, we need to get over the concept of to big to fail.
- gruseom 14y agoThe article says that without subsidies the big banks would about break even. Does that presuppose that toxic assets are recorded accurately in their books? I recall that there was controversy about this, and then the issue seemed to vanish. If toxic assets have not been accounted for accurately, how big is the discrepancy?
- tsotha 14y ago"Toxic" assets don't necessarily remain toxic. In the last few years the housing market has recovered somewhat, making the problem less urgent.
- droithomme 14y agoThat statement is disingenuous. Collateral based bad mortgages were a small fraction of the toxic assets. Banks only ended up forgiving around $20 billion in mortgage debt, which is nothing compare to the size of other issues. The bad mortgage issue has been a red herring from the beginning to distract attention from criminal fraud by bankers and absurdly focus on homeowners instead. Almost all of the toxic assets, or more properly, speculative loss that will never be paid, was on the derivatives market which could be as much as $1.2 quadrillion dollars, 20 times the size of the entire world economy, of which even the $16 trillion in bailouts was a small amount. The toxic assets have been moving around and ending up off of bank sheets and on federal government sheets as part of loan paybacks, which is more of the massive scam and stealth bailouts going on. Every one of these mega banks should be dismantled. The same scams continue.
- tsotha 14y ago>Almost all of the toxic assets, or more properly, speculative loss that will never be paid, was on the derivatives market which could be as much as $1.2 quadrillion dollars, 20 times the size of the entire world economy, of which even the $16 trillion in bailouts was a small amount. This is quite literally unbelievable. Do you have anything to back it up?
- btilly 14y agoI suspect that http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2012/05/top-derivatives-expert-finally-gives-a-credible-estimate-of-the-size-of-the-global-derivatives-market.html http://www.washingtonsblog.com/2012/05/top-derivatives-exper... or something like it is the source. In theory these unwind cleanly, and the actual risk is low. As the article says, if there is even a small discrepancy in how they unwind, the real numbers are insane. A big part of the freak out when Lehman failed is that everyone knew that in theory the deals would unwind, but it had never been tested in practice on anything like that scale.
- tsotha 14y agoI've never read anything I thought was credible from washingtonsblog, and this is no exception. The number is based largely on speculation, and if you follow the chain of blogs and investor articles the whole thing just stinks of the sort of hype you see when an investment site is trying to scare you.
- damoncali 14y agoThey're not talking about a one time thing, but a perpetual artificially low cost of capital afforded only to the largest banks, basically at the cost of everyone else.
- rayiner 14y agoVery interesting article, and it should be noted that while it's in the opinions section, it is an editorial by the editors. See: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-04-29/bloomberg-view-to-begin-publishing-editorials-in-late-may.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-04-29/bloomberg-view-to-b... It's not some random HuffPo piece... That said, the "profitability" of the big banks is somewhat irrelevant. JP Morgan, Goldman, etc, evolved out of partnerships, where all the profits went to the partners. To this day, the banks pay out most of their revenues as compensation. "Profits" are what's left after all that.
- nitid_name 14y ago>That said, the "profitability" of the big banks is somewhat irrelevant. JP Morgan, Goldman, etc, evolved out of partnerships, where all the profits went to the partners. To this day, the banks pay out most of their revenues as compensation. "Profits" are what's left after all that. Couldn't the argument be easily changed to "Big bank executive compensation is subsidized by taxpayers"?
- coditor 14y ago... and us nothing?
- JamisonM 14y agoThis analysis is a bit disingenuous, from the article: "The larger they are.. the result is an implicit subsidy: The banks that are potentially the most dangerous can borrow at lower rates, because creditors perceive them as too big to fail." As an implicit subsidy it is not as if there the 83 billion dollars that can be "taken away" from the banks and used for other purposes. The implicit government guarantee has value but if you can not find a way to recover that value in some other way when taking it away from the banks you would just be robbing the economy of that growth. That being said it seems like the way to remedy this would be to use a tax mechanism that can measure this subsidy and extract it from the banks in a manner that is fair to bank investors and citizens.
- damoncali 14y ago...or just break them up. Is it worth the extra .8% to risk the entire system?
- eek04 14y agoPresuming that the theory is correct, there seems to be two sides to this: First, you're going to be transferring that money to the banks/institutions that lend to them. So the money isn't going away, it's just ending up as profit for somebody else (as compensation for them considering themselves to be taking on more risk.) Second, the taxpayers going to get rid of that amount of cost in the form of risk; the averaged risk is paid by the taxpayers, it is just paid in bulk when the banks are about to fail. This assumes the calculations are all correct, and it doesn't count in what indirect cost the economy would have from loans getting a bit more expensive overall.
- damoncali 14y agoThis is the part that gets me, as I've been saying this for a while - Left unchecked, the superbanks could ultimately require bailouts that exceed the government’s resources. Picture a meltdown in which the Treasury is helpless to step in as it did in 2008 and 2009. Makes one side seem a little less important to me.
- 14y ago
- maceo 14y ago"In other words, the banks occupying the commanding heights of the U.S. financial industry -- with almost $9 trillion in assets, more than half the size of the U.S. economy -- would just about break even in the absence of corporate welfare." That's a brilliant observation. Props to Bloomberg for this incredibly lucid op-ed.
- redblacktree 14y agoI think we need to drop the concept of "too big to fail." If another large bank requires a bailout, let's give it to them, but make a Ma Bell-style breakup part of the deal. i.e. You get the bailout, but you can no longer be too big to fail.
- tsotha 14y agoWhy wait? Instead of the consolidation we've seen, what we should have done is increased reserve requirements and broken up the banks so they all had assets below a certain dollar figure. On top of that, they should be forbidden from owning securities related to other banks or insurance companies.
- mtgx 14y agoThis should've already happened, and should happen. The big banks can not be allowed to stay this big, otherwise there's almost definitely a repeat of the 2008 financial crisis in another decade or two.
- Zuider 14y agoHey! Who are you calling 'too big to fail'? I think they are failing just fine, epic even, thank you very much.
- chubbard 14y agoSo I thought this article was pretty opaque. They didn't really discuss the subsidy enough. They just said there was a subsidy that allowed the banks to borrow money at a reduced rate. Who is giving them this preferential treatment? How do those particular banks get that subsidy? Why not charge all banks the same rate and let the size of these banks eat themselves. It's not a hard concept to swallow if you've had economics 101. Law of diminishing returns which happens to any business when it gets too large. But, I think it didn't really layout a case for why this subsidy exists.
- dllthomas 14y agoLaw of diminishing returns doesn't work like that (they're not adding just a single factor of production), and you're fighting against economies of scale (which are also economics 101).
- damoncali 14y agoIt's not a real subsidy. They're saying that by allowing banks to get too big to fail, the banks are in a sense using the assets of the federal government as if they owned them. Everyone knows the feds will bail them out, so they can borrow money more cheaply than they would be able to otherwise.
- drucken 14y agoThe basis of this article is a May 2012 IMF Working Paper called "Quantifying Structural Subsidy Values for Systematically Important Financial Institutions" (http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/wp12128.pdf http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2012/wp12128.pdf). The subsidy discussed is not an issue of economics directly, but capital markets, i.e. finance. The paper infers a subsidy level for state-supported financial institutions by comparing the level of state support embedded in credit agency ratings and comparing them to their long-run average value. The authors control for the factors such as the sovereign's own ability to support, because sovereign debt is also rated by agencies, and for institutions intrinsic rating values. Credit ratings are used directly and indirectly by capital market participants to determine the level of funding costs across all debt markets. So, they are the best available proxy for determining at least a floor for this preferential rate. As can be seen from previous financial crises, actual bailouts would be highly dependent on the nature of crises and may be substantially higher than expected. How do those particular banks get that subsidy? - from other market participants. In a sense, governments are permitting the misallocation of capital from other market participants, including governments and government agencies (hence taxpayers are directly involved), into the state-supported institutions. It is not a zero-sum game because of how that capital is then used. Why not charge all banks the same rate and let the size of these banks eat themselves. - there is no central rate allocation. Market participants use market prices and their best available information for funding costs. A state-supported institution is naturally considered by many participants to be a lower risk than a non-state supported institution.
- b1daly 14y agoIn some sense the thesis of the article makes intuitive sense. How can the banking sector really have much of a margin since they are dealing with the ultimate commodity product, money! Trading is a zero sum game, all the banks can't make a profit doing it. Banks provide quasi governmental services to society, so one could make an argument that they should be subsided in some way, or that they have to be subsided! Their role in the economy is too fundamental to not have. I've come across arguments that banks should just be turned in to utilities. http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2011/08/should-banks-be-public-utilities.html http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2011/08/should-banks-be-publi...
- Aloisius 14y agoWait, what? Trading is not a zero sum game except for maybe options and futures contracts.
- b1daly 14y agoWell, buying and selling financial instruments with short holding times is a zero sum game. Any gain is created by another traders loss.
- Aloisius 14y agoYes, but banks more often hold large positions for long periods of time. While they do engage in HFT, it is hardly their only trading strategy.
- ajtaylor 14y agoI feel it's a little disingenuous to call it a "subsidy" since the taxpayers aren't actually writing the banks a check for $83 billion. But the key point is still spot on: without the implied backstop of a government bailout the banks would pay what everyone else must pay to borrow money, etc. Too big to fail is simply a euphemism these days for "The government will take care of everything no matter now stupid and reckless we act." This attitude really must go. How should that be accomplished? I don't know. One thing is for certain: the banks will drag their heels kicking and screaming should someone try to change the status quo. And they'll probably get their way - but it should still be attempted.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- drucken 14y ago... Because it is in the best (short and mid-term) interests of a debt-laden and debt-fuelled state to support those entities which can maximize further debt creation. Banks do not exist in isolation. You could go as far as to say the problem is not so much Too Big to Fail, though that produces its own problems, as Too Interconnected to Fail. These issues have only become worse since 2008.
- rayiner 14y ago> ... Because it is in the best interests of a debt-laden and debt-fuelled state to support those entities which can maximize further debt creation. How exactly?
- damoncali 14y agoI think he's saying we need cheap capital right about now, and this quasi-government lending machine is just about the only practical way to do that. But it's not a forever thing, and it's going to break again. Or as a character in Margin Call put it: "If you really want to do this with your life you have to believe that you’re necessary. And you are. People want to live like this in their cars and their big fucking houses that they can’t even pay for? Then you’re necessary. The only reason they all get to continue living like kings is because we’ve got our fingers on the scales in their favor. I take my hand off and the whole world gets really fucking fair really fucking quickly and nobody actually wants that. They say they do but they don’t. They want what we have to give them, but they also want to play innocent and pretend they have no idea where it came from. That’s more hypocrisy than I’m willing to swallow. Fuck them. Fuck normal people."
- damoncali 14y agoYou could go as far as to say the problem is not so much Too Big to Fail, though that produces its own problems, as Too Interconnected to Fail. This seems to be poorly understood and critically important. Too big, too connected, and too many people making the same bet at the same time with too much leverage. This will happen again unless something is done. And they went and made it worse...
- chrismealy 14y agoWe already let banks print money. What's another $83 billion?
- Aloisius 14y agoDoesn't the Bureau of Engraving and Printing (part of the Treasury) print money?
- dvdt 14y agoIn practice the Federal Reserve "prints" money when it purchases Treasury Bonds. Where does the Fed get the money from? That's the whole point--the Fed is able to create money out of thin air.
- jakerocheleau 14y agoI have seen this argument countless times but the BEP just gives money to the Fed. It's pathetic. From Wikipedia: > The Bureau of Engraving and Printing (BEP) is a government agency within the United States Department of the Treasury that designs and produces a variety of security products for the United States government, most notable of which is paper currency for the Federal Reserve.[1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bureau_of_Engraving_and_Printing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bureau_of_Engraving_and_Printin...
- Aloisius 14y agoNone of the banks talked about in this article can make money. Only the Federal Reserve Banks can. Equating one of the non-profit, tax-exempt Federal Reserve banks which are controlled by the Federal Government, but "owned" by member banks with a consumer finance bank is ridiculous. Heck this article is talking about subsidized bank borrowing costs. The Federal Reserve Banks have zero borrowing costs!
- OGinparadise 14y agoThe banks that are potentially the most dangerous can borrow at lower rates, because creditors perceive them as too big to fail. Great, so we all should go to borrow from huge banks, no doubt their lower rates are passed to the consumers, with the banks being caring and all.
- samstave 14y agoPeople need to refuse to pay their taxes until .gov does something about the bank fraud and criminality.
- aangjie 14y agoReminds of this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_disobedience https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_disobedience Though the context doesn't fit exactly. and is a weak point for the analogy, but still the idea is interesting.
- AUmrysh 14y agoHow do I refuse to pay when they take it directly out of my check?
- bruceboughton 14y agoGo on then...
- calhoun137 14y agoI love that we get these political discussions on hacker news, but I sometimes wish we as a community would spend as much time thinking about politics as we do thinking about programming and science. Big banks function very much as part of the government, in many ways the big banks determine government policy, certainly to a much greater extent than popular opinion does. There are many forms of this public-private merging of government. To take just one aspect, consider the revolving door whereby bank executives go between their banks and government jobs and back again: to just pick one example virtually at random, obamas chief of staff is a "former" citi group executive. I wonder, if a bank executive goes to washington for a little while, do they even notice that they changed jobs? This article explains that the big banks wouldn't even be profitable without massive tax payer support, here is a choice quote from the article which really drives home how intense the stranglehold banks have over government policy: "Neither bank executives nor shareholders have much incentive to change the situation. On the contrary, the financial industry spends hundreds of millions of dollars every election cycle on campaign donations and lobbying, much of which is aimed at maintaining the subsidy. The result is a bloated financial sector and recurring credit gluts." Some people wonder what could be done about such a situation. The sad truth is that there are already an overwhelming number of ideas that are floating around that have already been demonstrated to work (see iceland). The problem is not coming up with a good idea, the problem is how to implement one of the many good ideas which have already been proven to work. The crux of the matter is that only the power of a strong federal government can take on the even more powerful too big too fail banks. The only way political change happens is when people get organized, and the american political system gives us a lot of freedoms. If you live and a free country and abstain from participating in politics, then in my opinion you have abdicated your responsibility as a citizen.
- spoiledtechie 14y agoAmen. Speak it loud and Clear!
- shin_lao 14y agoYou make a couple of great points, but you're obviously extremely misinformed about Iceland. Basically what happened in Iceland is due to an amount of stupidity that greatly exceeds the amount we're used to in the rest of Europe and the USA (not implying that the people of Iceland are stupid, but they had incredibly incompetent people at the helm). They bailed out their banks as well, just wanted to make it look like they didn't. "[there are ideas] floating around that have already been demonstrated to work" is a bit of hyperbole and I'd love to see you get into the specifics. The sad truth, to me, is that we are responsible because we make our governments spend too much money.
- unabridged 14y agocitizens should get the money directly. why should a private bank be able to borrow at x% and sell the money to me at x+4%? if you are going to have the fed system the government should loan out mortgages directly at the same rate plus a fixed fee for a government approved appraiser.
- dschiptsov 14y agoBecause being successful cheater is better evolution strategy than being a drone.
- digitalengineer 14y agoI think Elisabeth Warren said it best when she asked "The Most Obvious Question Ever And Stumps A Bunch Of Bank Regulators" She asks federal bank regulators why no banks were taken to trial in the aftermath of the financial crisis. http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=mavB1lbtIow http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=m...
- alan_cx 14y agoAny one know how much it would cost to let a failing bank go down, but compensate the people with their money in that banks? I never found out why we couldn't let that happen. If a bank fails, and I have $10,000 in it, give me the money, not the failed bank. Then I can pick a new back, which should in theory be stronger with the new influx of customers form the now dead bank. Besides, what happened to capitalism and competition? We capitalists seem to ditch those principles the second it goes wrong, expecting socialist payouts from the people to bail them out. No, businesses go bust, that is the whole point. Survival of the fittest. Strength through competition. That is the American way, no? Worse still, was the bail out of the car industry. How did that happen? A whole load of new companies killed off right there. People would have left, some would start new firms, some would got an bolster existing firms, and so on. Now, the same stagnation remains because it was propped up. Ah, pah. Just another one of those things that leaves me depressed, confused, and cold.
- nickik 14y agoThe US allready has the FDIC, meaning that in every account you allready have 50k insured, witch would take care of the 'poor people who suffer the most'. Saving the banks was never about saving the poor who have money in the bank, or saving the 'banking system'. > That is the American way, no? Not anymore, banks are saved, so are car companys, motorcycle companys and so on. The 'socialist' swedenish let there car company fail.
- znowi 14y ago> I never found out why we couldn't let that happen. Because they frightened everyone with an imminent apocalypses if we were not to save their fraudulent asses. I believe we should have let them fail. It would not be pretty, but we'd manage. Long term benefits would surpass temporarily hardship. First it would cleanse the system and second set a strong precedent. Besides, it would be very much in terms with capitalism - failed in competition goes under. Yet funny how the banks that lobby for ever more independence, rely so heavily on social welfare from the government :)