25 ms·
Why is it a terrible idea?
by marssaxman 14y ago
Why is it a terrible idea?
- slifty 14y agoFor the record this was an oversight in the rush to get this out ASAP -- I'm correcting it now (thanks for calling it out!)
- benwerd 14y agoAh, you should probably think about recreating the Onion's look and feel, rather than grabbing their resources and literally copying it.
- Cryode 14y agoI'd hope you aren't correcting it by saving your own local copy of _their_ stylesheet...
- slifty 14y agoBaby steps people baby steps!
- unclebucknasty 14y agoI hear you and I applaud just about anybody who builds just about anything. But, it should never be a step (baby or otherwise) to completely take someone else's work. It's one thing to take cues from them. It's another thing to literally take their code without permission, even if it is "only CSS". That is really, really poor form from the start. If you don't think so, then try asking The Onion if they mind. Then you can have a clear conscience. But, if you are unwilling to even ask, well, then you really don't have to. You already know it's not cool. BTW, good luck with it.
- slifty 14y agoDon't worry -- we're in their circles ;) But regardless! As I mention in another place on this thread: The point of this project is the blunt comparison to The Onion -- the copying of the name, look, and feel of a well known and well recognized satirical publication is actually a vital part of the statement about our world and the media.
- csinchok 14y agoHi. I actually work as a developer at The Onion. Given the conversation we just had, I'd say that it seems like you're not in "our circles". Honestly, I think this idea is pretty cool, but just ripping off our CSS and HTML seems a little scummy. Not only that, but the fact that you were initially hotlinking our static media makes it seems like this is a bit of a lazy effort (let it be noted: you're still hotlinking a lot of media—now it's just from other sites). I'm actually a little sad that you stopped hotlinking our css, because we were already working on another stylesheet to mess with you. Beyond that, you're using our fonts. These are not free web fonts. They are fonts that we paid a good deal of money to be able to use legally on our site, and they are definitely not authorized for use on yours. Bottom line: cool idea, not OK execution.
- slifty 14y agoOh snap! Sorry I missed the boat on letting you have fun with the CSS (I'd be glad to point it back if you would enjoy it!) But yes, this was built in a few hours and most of that time was spent playing with caching and deployment. Not so much "lazy" as "rushed." (considering this is for the lulz, I'm OK with it being called rushed.) So yes, to be clear, this was a "lets have quick fun and make a satirical mashup" not a "lets spend a week designing a web site that looks like The Onion." Not sure where scum comes into play given that fact, but I'm sorry if the project pissed anyone off over there. In my experience different people react to détournement in different ways when they are the ones being shifted around. As for the circles, you're right about not us being in touch with the dev teams over there. Regarding fonts, noted; I'll wait and see if there is a formal response from The Onion on these fronts but you clearly know the first-hand vibe -- if that's upsetting people I can remove them. As for the other media we're aware of that and will be making a move soon, THERE ARE ONLY SO MANY FINGERS ON A HAND!
- sp332 14y agoRegarding fonts: it's not the Onion you really have to worry about, but the actual owner of the fonts. That's who is going to come after you for copyright infringement.
- 14y ago
- taproot 14y agoBecause if the onion goes down, so does your site. Because the onion can take the link down just to mess with you. Because the onion gets owned, or feels like it, they can have "fun" with your users and your site. Edit: its only a bad idea if you care about the integrity of your site, for something like this it probably doesn't matter.
- baby 14y agoAlso hotlinking has always been looked down upon.
- marssaxman 14y agoGood reasons. Thanks for explaining.
- slifty 14y agoWell, the big concern is that those look like cache files, which means they could just go away at any second. In the rush to launch I didn't care, but I should be more careful / make the change before that link just dies.
- chc 14y agoBesides what everyone else said, hotlinking other people's resources has been considered bad form since the early days of the Web, and its legality is questionable as well.
- marssaxman 14y agoI've been around since the early days of the web and I never understood why other people decided it ought to be bad form. You put it out there to be downloaded, why shouldn't people download it?
- redthrowaway 14y agoBecause it means they pay to host and serve it, while you reap the benefits.
- chc 14y agoHotlinking is specifically in contrast to downloading.
- marssaxman 14y agoAnd yet there is no technical difference. Browsing is downloading. It seems strange to make up non-technical rules about when downloading a piece of data is or is not OK. If The Onion has a problem with the amount of data they are serving, perhaps they should configure their server to reject those requests; putting the onus on the end user not to issue HTTP GET unless a certain non-technical context exists seems.... odd. I understand that this idea has gained currency over the last decade, but I still don't understand or agree with it.
- chc 14y agoThere is a huge technical difference between downloading your own copy of a file that you then serve to your visitors and pointing all your traffic at somebody else's server. No engineer in the world would look at those two plans and say, "Eh, I can't tell any difference." > If The Onion has a problem with the amount of data they are serving, perhaps they should configure their server to reject those requests; putting the onus on the end user not to issue HTTP GET unless a certain non-technical context exists seems.... odd. No clue what you're talking about. For one, we're talking about website creators here rather than end users, and it's these website creators' failure to issue an HTTP GET that's considered bad manners.
- sp332 14y agoIn addition to the other answers, I'd like to add that's it's not very friendly. Why should The Onion have to pay for the bandwidth to host your stylesheet? They pay for every time someone visits your site.
- kansface 14y agoThey can trivially swap out that file for their choice of stuff you don't want on your website. They can do it for every 1/1000 requests so you don't know wtf is going on. They can use the host header to only do this to your website. They can simply delete it and your content is gone.