3 ms·
The problem(s) with OpenID (excellent criticism of OpenID)
- nickb 19y agoOpenID seems to be doomed. All these issues are just horrible on their own... taken as a whole, it's a disaster.
- wmf 19y agoA purely negative article tends to give that impression. What's the alternative? Brands likes to mention how perfect Credentica is, but it isn't deployed anywhere. OpenID may turn out to be the worst identity protocol, except for all the others that have been tried.
- benhoyt 19y agoGood point. Similar to IP and TCP -- from an embedded programmer's perspective, IP is one of the most icky and hardware-unfriendly protocols around. When my friend was at university, they told them about IP just in passing, saying, "it'll die any day now." But now it's everywhere, and it works.
- bct 19y agoThe security problems the article lists can be broken down like this: - phishing - if a relying party is insecure, bad things can happen to it - if your ID provider is insecure, very bad things can happen Those aren't anything new, and they're not fundamental to OpenID. Then he goes into "what if my provider is evil?", "what if i don't want my ids unified?" and "but there's no trust!", which are usually pretty good indicators that the speaker doesn't grok OpenID.
- cstejerean 19y agoWhile there are certainly problems that need to be addressed, problems with phishing need to be addressed by any web application. While there is certainly room for improvement I think OpenID at least has the right idea about how single sign-on for the web needs to work.
- jsmcgd 19y agoCan't the first problem (phishing) be overcome with a simple browser plugin?
- DougBTX 19y agoNo, but a browser plugin would be a great platform to launch a phishing attack.
- dzohrob 19y agoi just can't imagine a regular user ever really understanding why (or how) their username for a bunch of websites is a URL.
- bct 19y agoLots of sites make you log in with your email address, is that any different?