3 ms·
As the guy who signs bills into law, and as the head of his party (meaning that he dictates how they are going to be whipped) he is lawmaker number 1.
by pessimizer 14y ago
As the guy who signs bills into law, and as the head of his party (meaning that he dictates how they are going to be whipped) he is lawmaker number 1.
- btilly 14y agoThe President is not the head of the party (Debbie Wasserman Schultz is to the extent that the position exists), nor is he in charge of whipping people (for the Democrats that's Steny Hoyer right now). He admittedly does have a huge bully pulpit. A defined legislative role. And he does personally lean on representatives. But the US has absolutely nothing equivalent to the organization and party discipline that countries. And "President" is an individually elected position by the country, and has no particular relation to his party other than "(very prominent) member".
- pessimizer 14y agoThe chair of the DNC is not (even a little bit) the leader of the party, and the Whip is not the person who determines what policy people are to be whipped to. A sitting President is always the head of their party.
- btilly 14y agoCitation needed. My understanding of US political parties says that they do not have a rigid structure nor a single head. Indeed if you look through the section on the structure of the Democratic Party on Wikipedia (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_Party_(United_States)#Current_structure_and_composition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_Party_(United_States... - really, go look) you won't find Barack Obama's name anywhere in that section. The President has a huge bully pulpit. He is in charge of one of the 3 branches of government. The public hears and sees the President. But the President does not run the party.
- chimeracoder 14y ago> he is lawmaker number 1. The president is a member of the executive branch, not the legislative branch. He signs bills into law in his authority as an executive who will be responsible for carrying out the laws that the legislators write, not as a legislator responsible for creating those laws. You absolutely cannot say that he is "lawmaker number 1", because he's not even a lawmaker. The fact that most presidents happen to have served as legislators (senators) previously is irrelevant; that was their job then, and this is their job now. He is not the head of his party. Nor is he the one who dictates how they will (or should) be whipped - the President isn't even supposed to have any say in the process of whipping votes - that falls on Reid, Pelosi, etc. (who actually have the resources to whip legislators, since they can make promises of campaign money, etc.) We live in an era where the power of the executive has been illegally expanded well beyond what it was originally intended to be - we can thank Bush and Obama for the bulk of that (at least most recently). But that does not actually change the role that the president has (or should have) in legislative matters.
- coldpie 14y agoYou might be interested in the phrase "realpolitik". The phrase comes from Germany in the mid-1800s. "Realpolitik" refers to politics as they actually occur, as opposed to the idealized interpretation you were taught in middle school, for example. America has never in its history operated according to the ideal. It's just easier to become informed in America in 2013 than it was 150 years ago, so the discrepancies between the ideal and the realpolitik are more obvious. I guess this boils down to whether you find manipulating the realpolitik to be more or less effective than trying to eliminate it.
- dragonwriter 14y agoThe President may be nominal head of the party, but whips take direction, insofar as they take it at all, from the caucus leadership in the house of Congress in which they sit, not from the general leadership of the party. The US doesn't have a strong unitary party system of the kind you might find in a typical Westminster system (of course, in a Westminster system, the head of government would also be the leader of the party sitting in the primary house of the legislature, not a separately-elected official outside of that house.)