14 ms·
Ohio State develops clean coal technology
- networked 14y agoThis sounds downright revolutionary. Could someone with domain knowledge comment if this is really such a new thing? The press release says, >In chemical looping, the coal isn't burned with fire, but instead chemically combusted in a sealed chamber so that it doesn't pollute the air. A second combustion unit in the lab does the same thing with coal-derived syngas, and both produce 25 thermal kilowatts of energy. How much coal does it take to produce those 25 kW? You'd think efficiency is what most readers would want to hear about at this point because everything else sounds pretty great. A page linked [1] from the press release states that >New technologies that use fossil fuels should not raise the cost of electricity more than 35 percent, while still capturing more than 90 percent of the resulting carbon dioxide. but it is unclear if this is mostly due to the price of extra coal or the equipment itself. [1] http://researchnews.osu.edu/archive/looping203.htm http://researchnews.osu.edu/archive/looping203.htm
- uvdiv 14y agoYou'd think efficiency is what most readers would want to hear about at this point because everything else sounds pretty great. It's necessarily less efficient than coal power without CO2 capture. From these slides [1] they estimate 35%, vs. 39% for a conventional coal plant, and 29% for a different type of CO2 capture (post-combustion CO2 scrubbing with monoethanolamine [MEA]). ...but it is unclear if this is mostly due to the price of extra coal or the equipment itself. Mostly equipment/capital [1]. [1] http://www.netl.doe.gov/publications/proceedings/12/co2capture/presentations/3-Wednesday/LS%20Fan-OSU-CDCL.pdf http://www.netl.doe.gov/publications/proceedings/12/co2captu...
- ams6110 14y agocoal isn't burned with fire, but instead chemically combusted I'd like some clarification on the difference between "fire" and "chemical combustion"
- uvdiv 14y agoOne definition of "fire" demands "oxygen from the air": https://www.google.com/search?q=define+fire&oq=define+fire&ie=UTF-8&hl=en https://www.google.com/search?q=define+fire&oq=define+fi... The fuel here doesn't react with air, but with a solid oxidiser (Fe2O3). It's a solid-solid reaction, whose products are gases (CO2 and H2O). Just like a solid-fuel rocket.
- fghh45sdfhr3 14y agoAnd how is CO2 form Fe2O3 different than CO2 from the air? Is it just that it is easy to capture? Then what?
- ajross 14y agoIt's not different, but it's a pure gas and not mixed with a ton of nitrogen that air combustion exhaust would be. That makes it trivial to capture (literally just pump it through a compressor into a tank). One important point, though, is that the sequestration problem is not actually addressed here. This just gets you conveniently-produced tanks of CO2 (or crates of dry ice, whatever). What you do with that to keep it out of the atmosphere is still an open problem.
- Gravityloss 14y agoThank you, now it makes some sense. These press releases are next to useless.
- smurph 14y agoIt unclear where all of the carbon dioxide goes after they capture it. Does the process actually use the carbon dioxide for a second reaction? Or do they just put it in a tank somewhere? If it's the later, this would be difficult to do at scale.
- lifeformed 14y agoSell it to PepsiCo!
- uvdiv 14y agoIt's meant to be injected underground.
- Gravityloss 14y agoBut given coal has perhaps 500 kg/m^3 of carbon while pure CO2 at ambient pressure has about 0.5 kg/m^3. A thousand fold difference. How are you going to dig something up from the ground, expand it thousand fold and put it back in to the same hole? I don't understand this carbon storage business. Clearly coal is the best carbon storage method by far, and it doesn't cost anything as it's already stored.
- wlesieutre 14y agoYou can also store it in the holes that you took natural gas out of. I'm not aware of it being done on any large scale, but it's been talked about a lot.
- nitrogen 14y agoIt would be pressurized before storage. However, to reach 500kg/m^3 it looks like it will be close to becoming a liquid: http://www.wolframalpha.com/share/clip?f=d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427equv6b77jb http://www.wolframalpha.com/share/clip?f=d41d8cd98f00b204e98...
- Gravityloss 14y ago
- JPKab 14y agoAs a person whose roots in Appalachia (West Virginia/southwest Virginia border) go back a long ways, I'd love to see someone talk about the other dirty aspect of coal: the way its mined. I get the feeling that a very large percentage of the population has no idea that they are literally blowing the tops off of mountains throughout Appalachia to get this stuff. Anyone who thinks this is acceptable has proably never been to a site where it has been done(it looks like the surface of the moon), or lived near a creek which gets filled in with the massive amounts of runoff from it. I wish they would go after coal the old fashioned way, but it is more expensive and more dangerous that way.
- rickdale 14y agoRight, in correct terms there is no such thing as 'clean coal'
- criley 14y agoUsing these definitions that include the entirety of the process, no energy is clean energy except for Sunlight + 6CO2 + 6H2O -> C6H1206 +6O2. Even solar power will have something "dirty" along the chain somewhere. The closest we can get is to "offset" the dirtiness.
- skore 14y agoDitto for nuclear. Had my fair share of discussion with neckbeards on the Internet touting how incredibly clean nuclear energy is. You know, as long as you leave out the mining (radon emissions being one of the commonly known issues, the chemicals involved in mining not as well known; furthermore, many mines don't get any cleanup after decommission) and the storage of the nuclear waste (which is simply an unsolved problem). But hey, less CO2, right?
- melling 14y agoWell, what is the lesser of all evils? We need lots of energy, and it's only going to get worse as India, China, and the rest of the world come online.
- msisk6 14y agoSounds like a variation on coal gasification: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_gasification http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_gasification The article is a bit scant on details like by-products or the emissions from the combustion of the syngas in the secondary combustion process. And, whenever I hear "Clean Coal" I feel like someone is trying too hard to sell me on something. This whole article reads like it was written by the coal industry.
- JPKab 14y agoYou better believe this research was funded by the coal industry. And my god, the way it is written, I would be embarrassed to be an OSU alumni. I realize that all public research universities do this crap, including my alma mater Virginia Tech, but I hate it when they do. Seriously, the tone of the article reeks of political campaigning. With Virginia and Ohio, two coal producing states that are now both swing states, you can bet that coal will continue to get tons of attention from the Federal government.
- protomyth 14y agoThis will probably be a big help for China if it is cheap enough given their use of coal. Coal is what we used to get to our current status and it will be what everyone else uses unless we come up with something cheaper and just as constant.
- bradleyjg 14y agoWhenever you seed the phrase 'clean coal' check for you wallet. There are many irreducible problems with coal. First, you've got to get it out of the ground. The most common ways of doing that are strip mining and mountain top removal mining. Both not only destroy the area actually minded but produce enormous amounts of liquid and solid waste (coal slurry and fly ash are the worst) that destroy whatever environment they are deposited into. Second, however you cut it, the fundamental chemical reaction is going to be CxHxOx + O2 => CO2. There is no way to avoid producing carbon dioxide if you want and exothermic reaction. So you get carbon dioxide capture schemes. The problem is once you capture the carbon dioxide no one has any idea what to do with. There are vague notions that we can pump it underground, but pilot projects in this area have been dismal failures both because of a lack of confidence that the CO2 will remain buried and because of the high energy costs in burying the CO2. Third, aside from CO2, coal has a variety of other nasty constituents: mercury, uranium, thorium, arsenic among others.
- rdtsc 14y ago> Third, aside from CO2, coal has a variety of other nasty constituents: mercury, uranium, thorium, arsenic among others. How high is the radiological pollution from coal I wonder? All that stuff gets turned to ash and spread around by wind and now it will be some kind of slurry I guess. Still have to do something with it.
- TeMPOraL 14y ago"Coal power stations, for example, expose the public to nuclear radiation, because coal ash typically contains uranium. Indeed, according to a paper published in the journal Science, people in America living near coal-fired power stations are exposed to higher radiation doses than those living near nuclear power plants." "–People in America living near coal-fired power stations are exposed to higher radiation doses than those living near nuclear power plants. Source: McBride et al. (1978). Uranium and thorium have concentrations of roughly 1 ppm and 2 ppm respectively in coal. Further reading: gabe.web.psi.ch/research/ra/ra res.html, www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~wilkins/energy/Companion/E20.12.pdf.xpdf." http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c24/page_168.shtml http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c24/page_16... http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c24/page_175.shtml http://www.inference.phy.cam.ac.uk/withouthotair/c24/page_17...
- jstalin 14y agoClean coal is a lie. The byproducts of coal usage are stored in gigantic ash ponds. In 2008, one such pond ruptured and spread 5.4 million cubic yards of waste containing mercury, arsenic, lead, and thallium (amongst other things) all over eastern Tennessee. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/27/us/27sludge.html?_r=0 https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/27/us/27sludge.html?_r=0
- ebbv 14y agoGee I wonder who funded this research? Hrmm.... Mining coal is hugely destructive, even if we take a logical leap and just believe that this really is "clean coal" for creating power. It's a waste of time. Solar, Wind, Geothermal and intelligent Hydro are the way forward. Everything else is just a bad compromise.
- SwellJoe 14y agoIt's sad, to me, that so much research continues to go into fossil fuels. We are so close to cost parity from renewable sources of energy; and, in some cases, it's already cheaper to use solar or wind energy, if you amortize over a long enough period (solar panels can last up to 50 years, with very little maintenance). Why do we have to dig up and burn every ounce of coal and oil and natural gas? Why not divert all of that effort, money, and time, into something that will last until the death of our sun? In a few years time, we'll all have cheaper power, and far fewer concerns about the destructive means by which the fuel is obtained. Even with zero emission (though not zero waste) coal power generation, there's still tremendous environmental and human life impact from its mining. There are 30 coal mining deaths per year in the US alone (which has more stringent safety standards and more modern equipment than almost anywhere else in the world that mines coal). I mean, this is cool and all. But, it doesn't solve the problem of coal being a limited resource that is dangerous and ecologically destructive to obtain.
- rhokstar 14y ago...but it's still coal and coal is dirty.
- beatpanda 14y agoSo just to play devil's advocate: there's already a bunch of mined coal out there, and you'd better believe it's going to get used by someone to create energy. Extracting that energy can either release CO2 into the atmosphere and contribute to total ecosystem collapse, or not. The only other alternative is that, somehow, existing coal doesn't get used at all, and if you could concoct a scenario where that's plausible, I'd be very impressed. When it comes to climate change we're talking about irreparable harm to the planet, mass extinction, and a serious existential threat to our species. Without minimizing the social and environmental problems created by coal mining, I think it's correct to say they are lesser problems than those posed by climate change. I absolutely agree that in general, civilization can do better than digging shit out of the ground and burning it, and I think the long term solution is wind, solar, geothermal, tidal, and so on. Unfortunately we don't have time to wait for a perfect solution, and we have huge amounts of fossil fuel reserves that, if they're all conventionally burned, will kill us all. So what can we do?
- bradleyjg 14y agoThe stocks of mined but unused coal are pretty small. It's very bulky and so expensive to store. Even oil doesn't have all that much storage, which is why when the market went into high contango traders had to rent oil tankers to store the oil they were buying on the spot market. As for CO2, the method the article is talking about makes it convenient to capture CO2 (at an energy cost) but transporting and storing it once captured are far more difficult problems.