4 ms·
OT, but I find it amazing that the triangle of desirable traits applies in so many places. There's the obvious "faster, cheaper, better. pick any two" and yeste
by malandrew 14y ago
OT, but I find it amazing that the triangle of desirable traits applies in so many places. There's the obvious "faster, cheaper, better. pick any two" and yesterday I heard another one "sane, smart and beautiful, pick two", which I'm sure has a corollary like "handsome, sensitive and rich, pick two". It's as if Brook's "no silver bullet" can be applied to just about everything our life (or it's just that easy to pick three desirable traits that are often mutually exclusive of one another)
- kyllo 14y agoYes, and then there are the Venn diagrams that describe the disappointing result of any combination of two desirable traits. Here's one humorous example: http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-7L9xAjgoZxo/ToydjJ7Hb8I/AAAAAAAABGo/RPXfXUrZ6Fw/s1600/317212_10150861168580525_787565524_21315273_1613530842_n.jpg http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-7L9xAjgoZxo/ToydjJ7Hb8I/AAAAAAAABG...
- bussiem 14y agoAm I the only one who flared in anger that "Smart" and "Nice" combined to be the "negative trait" of Nerd? And that according to this we cannot be "Handsome"? Inane crap like this helps absolutely nobody, and it perpetuates stereotypes that I think on HN we would be trying to avoid. Why you would post this is beyond me.
- zem 14y agoyeah, that fascinates me too. there are even some actual theorems, like brewer's cap theorem [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAP_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAP_theorem] and arrow's voting paradox [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrows_impossibility_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrows_impossibility_theorem], that take the "pick any two" form.
- javert 14y agoThat "amazing triangle" idea is just nonsense. For example, computers have gotten faster, better, AND cheaper over time. There definitely are women who are sane, smart, and beautiful. Are you kidding me? Just walk around any research university where they're doing graduate-level research and you will see lots of them. As for the other gender triangle, pg is definitely handsome, sensitive and rich, so there's your disproof. The "no silver bullet" thing is talking about something totally different. And it's an observation specific to software engineering (or, possibly, other specific domains, considered individually). There is a silver bullet for vaccinating against polio, but not for classroom teaching techniques.
- huherto 14y agoThe point that breaks the triangle(rectangle?) is if you add whether or not she is interested on you.
- javert 14y agoYes and no. Yes, you're correct. No, she's not interested. :P
- ssw1n 14y agoAdd this point before yours: whether or not she is taken already. If you find a smart, sane and beautiful woman doing graduate research, it is highly probable that she is already married or planning for marriage with her boyfriend/partner as soon as she is out of school. (Well, this is from my experiences in Science and Engineering departments. Might be different for other fields.)
- malandrew 14y agofaster, better, AND cheaper *over time*. If it happened over time, it wasn't done faster. Speed in terms of processor is synonymous with "better" (or at least one of the aspects of "better"). A better processor is a faster processor. Faster in the original expression refers to when you want something done/completed/delivered by.
- clebio 14y agoIt might be that three traits usually represent an arbitrary number of dimensions sufficiently well (factor analysis, PCA). Or that thinking about more than three gets very hard (number of distinct combinations), so we just resort to three. For that matter, two dimensions, or even just the poles of one, are enough for most people (2-party politics, a/theist, occidental/orient, etc.).
- bcgraham 14y agoIn general, it breaks down into "less time discount," "more of what other people want," "more of what I want". That's a simplification, but broadly speaks to the tensions in the system. I used to like this system because it helped identify the tradeoffs, but what I found most surprising about it was how often it didn't apply at all, in business/products/jobs but what was most in egregious violation of the principle were people. Some people just don't have a lot of upside to knowing; other people walk around with some nominal flaws, but for the most part are inspiring.