2 ms·
Note the distinguishing keyword marked in the first sentence: public good. In economics, as well as many other area of study like sociologicaly, security, busi
by belorn 14y ago
Note the distinguishing keyword marked in the first sentence: public good.
In economics, as well as many other area of study like sociologicaly, security, businesses, and hundred of area more, a key aspect is doing cost-benefit analyzes. It is a core tool, and often the first tool used when deciding what is public good, what is a good regulative action, what is an good incentive for further production of goods.
Copyright lack such cost-benefit analyze. It lacks even the discussion of doing one. The government gives out an state enforced protection again copying (ie a monopoly), and it doesn't even ask the question if it cost society more than it gives.
I agree with Richard Posner. Copyright is a trade off. however, as it is currently implemented, no such trade off is actually made. That is using 19th century government procedural being still used in the 21th.
Last to quote Eben Moglen, a professor in legal history:
"The great moral question of the twenty-first century is this: if all knowing, all culture, all art, all useful information can be costlessly given to everyone at the same price that it is given to anyone; if everyone can have everything, anywhere, all the time, why is it ever moral to exclude anyone?"