5 ms·
They are certainly quick to use the word "illegal" where others would say "fair use". I'd be more interested in the answer to the question, "what are you going
by jrockway 14y ago
They are certainly quick to use the word "illegal" where others would say "fair use".
I'd be more interested in the answer to the question, "what are you going to do about it". Sue someone who made Yoda into a vase? Sue Thingverse for letting people copy your precious, precious innovations? Sue Makerbot for being popular enough to register on your radar, even though 3D printing and CNC machines have been available for decades?
It should be interesting to see. But like creators of music and movies, creators of physical items may be disappointed with the law's effectiveness in this area.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 14y ago> They are certainly quick to use the word "illegal" where others would say "fair use". The article is reasonably balanced. We don't know yet if the courts see this as fair use or illegal because it hasn't been tested yet. But the DMCA notices are working; Thingverse has had a few and they've taken things down. So, "as 3-D printing becomes more accessible, copyright questions arise". Rights holders may try a big grab early on to attempt control and to influence concepts of what's acceptable. "Want a Yoda? Buy this plan. But you're not allowed to transform it." As you say it's not likely to work. I'm pleased that 3d printing got started with no DRM. But it's sad that rights-holders are not recognising the power of the masses to create and develop their properties. "Here's a model of X. Let's see what you can do!" and then putting the results on a website would generate sales.
- monochromatic 14y agoIn what way does printing a bust of Yoda involve fair use at all?
- jrockway 14y agoIn the same way that taking a snapshot of a building does not infringe on the building designer's copyright.
- monochromatic 14y agoThat's... not much of an analogy.
- summerdown2 14y agoI can sit at home and sculpt a block of wax into Yoda. Then I can make that wax into a resin model, all perfectly legally. Or, I can get a machine to make me a resin model. Why should there be a difference?
- dclowd9901 14y agoI thought it was more interesting that they manufactured copyright worries, since no existing copyright-happy company has shown any interest in any of these technologies presenting a problem as of yet. I get the need to make news interesting by presenting counterpoints, but if there isn't one yet, why are they positing on it? That's the place of opinion pages, not news reporting...