5 ms·
How Samsung is out-innovating Apple
- cubicle67 14y agohttp://ihkdesigns.wordpress.com/2013/02/19/idiots-are-everywhere/ http://ihkdesigns.wordpress.com/2013/02/19/idiots-are-everyw... in short: "I suggest you avoid the article at all costs. It is one of the most idiotic things I have ever read on the Internet, and I have read every single article by Dan Lyons!"
- criley 14y agoThe author of that retort redefines "sour grapes". Every quote on that blog is dripping with Apple-is-god and Android-is-horrific. In short, it's the kind of tripe he claim's the CNN article is, and it's absolutely unsubstantiated fanboy drivel. The way the author casually condescends the digitized stylus and larger size -- features that drove 15,000,000 sales in under a year -- reminds me of Apple itself, who likely also writes off this entire market segment. Honestly, when you get this kind of a vulgar response to your article, you know you're hitting on a nerve. And I agree with the original article: Apple's software has been playing catchup for multiple versions, isn't introducing novel features and is barely keeping up with the competition. I agree because I recently ditched iOS for Android for this very reason!
- cubicle67 14y agoand your comment completes the cycle? but seriously, it's all very silly. I see it all as good fun, like cheering for your team at the footy - of course the other team sucks!
- w0utert 14y ago>> And I agree with the original article: Apple's software has been playing catchup for multiple versions, isn't introducing novel features and is barely keeping up with the competition Playing catchup with what? Please enlighten me, what innovative great features have other platforms introduced since -let's say- iOS 4, that Apple has been forced to 'catch up' with in iOS 5 and 6? The only thing I can think of is Apple Maps, which desperately needs to catch up with Google Maps. But considering you can still use Google Maps on iOS I don't really think we can write off iOS because Apple Maps is weak.
- DominikR 14y agoNotification Center.
- digerata 14y agoInter-app communication. But this article was shit. If you like a stylus fine. But that is not innovation. I have 50 Treo styluses to sell you.
- criley 14y agoIt IS innovation. 1024 levels of pressure on a 5.5" 720p screen that lasts 18 hours. That's fantastic and I've not seen that in any device. Stop calling things "not innovation" just because it doesn't impress you. No one put out a stylus like this, in a device like this, with software like this. The old Palm's don't compare.
- digerata 14y agoIt's not innovation. It's incremental at best.
- altcognito 14y agoActually, the entire ios interface is dated in comparison to both Microsoft's platform and Android. Slapping a bunch of icons that can be paged back and forth isn't cutting it anymore as an interface.
- chmars 14y agoDefine 'Android' and 'Microsoft's platform'? Microsoft's platform is most likely Windows 8 but what's about 'Android'? There are many different GUIs for Android devices after all …
- corresation 14y agoI don't know the specifics of iOS 4, or why you chose that. But will simply respond regarding what Apple has, shall we say, emulated. How about setting up the device without having to tether it to a "real" computer? Android came out, day one, as a self-contained, empowered computer. iOS came out as a device that was expected to have an umbilical to a computer. How about multitasking? Apple's flavor of multitasking (the freeze-drying of processes, etc) was a virtual mirror of Android's. I would say notification center, but the notification center in iOS is absolutely atrocious (it is almost entirely a spam vehicle for games to post solicitations). It is years behind Android there. The widely heralded iCloud offers functionality (device backup, etc) in Android years earlier. Voice commands...in Android years earlier. Apple is brilliant at marketing every difference, but they most certainly were behind. My iPad (3rd generation) is a glorious web appliance (Safari on iOS remains by far the best mobile browser), however iOS itself feels incredibly stale in comparison to my GS III or my wife's Nexus 4.
- dylangs1030 14y agoMost of this response was ad hominem. You didn't really respond to the author's point-by-point critique of the article and Samsung's actual lack of innovation.
- makomk 14y agoHis "point-by-point critique" looks to me like yet another Apple fanboy loudly yelling about how any functionality Apple hardware doesn't have is both un-innovative and useless and how no-one could possibly need it. Particularly this part: "Split screen apps? I think that split screen apps wouldn’t work well on a phone, where you don’t want your focus to be diverted. But lets assume that you want such a feature–do you call that innovation?" (Some common tasks you might want to do on a smartphone require interacting with more than one app - but no, obviously it's completely useless!) Most of Apple's "innovations" in iOS weren't terribly innovative by that standard either, from what I recall.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- shanelja 14y agoI don't see why you think that, while it may all be opinion with little hard facts, I would hardly describe it as idiotic. This article may be pro-samsung in a way in which most pro-apple articles are anti-samsung, but it would be unfair for us to faun over one of them but exclude the other one, it just leads to fanboyism - if we are going to have biased articles, we may as well be unbiased about the directions of the bias. (that was a mouth full!)
- _Simon 14y agoSoporific is a much better adjective for this article.
- wsc981 14y agoI'm an Apple-aficionado, so perhaps I'm not completely objective in this matter, but the article didn't convince me that Samsung is really out-innovating Apple. Practically the only thing that's being noted is an option to run apps side-by-side. Personally I don't think it's that big a deal and I'm not sure Apple will ever build an option like that in iOS. I think Apple's next big innovation is probably not on the mobile platform, but in the living room instead. There have been rumours of an Apple-branded TV for quite some time now and Steve Jobs himself noted in an interview how he was annoyed that television sets were still pretty hard to use. I'm betting Apple will release a television in 2013 with no remote control, using Siri instead. Perhaps a nice iTunes integration as well for on-demand television. Perhaps Siri-controlled iTunes integration. When that happens people will remember why Apple is known to innovate and others are known to follow Apple's lead. That said, it will be interesting to see what features iOS 7 and the iPhone 6 (5S?) will bring. There's been some changes within Apple. With Jonathan Ive responsible for UI interaction we might expect some big changes. It will be interesting to see what his influence will be.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Kylekramer 14y agoIf you are serious, I'd love to take that bet on a Siri controlled TV in 2013.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kram8 14y agoThis article is really not worth reading - it has no content which is worth the time reading. Only the information that "Samsung is innovating at a faster pace than Apple can" without any evidence of this statement.
- mmariani 14y agoIf it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, looks like a duck, it's a duck. s/duck/ad/g
- blisterpeanuts 14y agoMay I humbly suggest, for the sake of grammar: s/a\sduck/an ad/g
- speeder 14y agoI found funny how much people are bashing the stylus. I don't get it. I bought 4 weeks ago (and last week it got destroyed in a flood :( ) a resistive-screen 7 inch tablet, and I loved it. At first, I got annoyed, because light touches did not worked, until I remembered that I could use plastic stylus with it, also my nails, other random objects, and so on. Then I started to use it primarily instead of my Xperia Play, even having way worse hardware, because it was so much easy to use, with the stylus I can visit non-mobile webpage and click small links without issues, also I can draw, and so several other things, much easier. But hey, I always hated touchscreens (I own a Xperia Play because at least to play games it has buttons, and I needed a smartphone, because after 5 years developing for them, not owning one was silly at least), so, don't mind me.
- dexen 14y agoI have used, and loved, the handwritting recognition of Sony Ericsson P910i. It was very fast to use -- while stylus based. Every friend of mine who dared to try it loved it instantly. I wonder how it stacks, long term, against finger-based on-screen keyboard of current breed of iDevices.
- cbs 14y agoI found funny how much people are bashing the stylus. On the surface they're a downright goofy looking non-necessity, but as a dude that spends all day developing a touch UI, with that much interaction I had to get one and now I can't go without one personally or professionally.
- mikecane 14y agoAnyone who wants better multi-windowing than a Galaxy Note 10.1 can jailbreak their iPad and use Quasar. Some will object that's a user hack. Well, it's also a user hack that lets the Note 10.1 use more than the 20 apps designed for it to also multi-window.
- taligent 14y agoJust remember who the author is here: http://www.businessinsider.com/commenter?id=4cc19fa8cadcbb92103c0000 http://www.businessinsider.com/commenter?id=4cc19fa8cadcbb92...
- corresation 14y agoWhat does your link prove? They seem to be a technology columnist. It is bizarre how people are either desperately telling people that they needn't look at this article -- for it shall pervert their minds -- or are attacking the author. I haven't even read the article but it must be good if it yields this sort of knee-jerk response.
- neya 14y agoBy using his own logic, you can dig into his own comments and find out easily that Taligent is a well-known anything pro-Apple troll here, so you're safe to ignore him.
- loyals 14y agoCompetitors have built upon the foundation Apple laid in mobile and are now leapfrogging it with bunch of useful features you can't find on iPhones and iPads. --- i just stopped reading afterwards.
- JuDue 14y agoApple has been quiet. Mini-fying devices doesn't quite cut it as innovation. Although Apple is doing it exceptionally well. But just because they aren't releasing anything monthly, and in 10 different form factors, does not mean they aren't developing stuff to be released when they think it is ready. Most companies pump stuff out and let the consumer decide. Rather than building one perfect phone, they release 20 and call it innovation. Apple never works that way.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoApple has 4 models of MacBooks and 4 models of iPods.
- JuDue 14y agoWhich is nothing compared to Samsung.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoQuote from a recent Marco Arment blog: "The four-product lineup is long gone. Today, Apple ships 24 distinct iPhone hardware models in two screen sizes. The iPad is even more diverse: 48 distinct hardware models, two screen sizes, and two densities of the larger size. They also sell 34 iPods, and a surprisingly diverse and conflicted notebook line."
- allwein 14y ago24 different models is different from the 20 different products mentioned above. I don't consider a White 16GB WiFi iPad 4 to be an entirely different product from a Black 16GB Wifi iPad 4. The 4-product lineup Marco is talking about was the old Apple Matrix of Consumer/Pro and Desktop/Mobile comprising the iBook, PowerBook, iMac, and PowerMac.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoConsidering how much trouble Apple's had shipping white versions of some of it's products, maybe you should?
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThe unstated nugget is that Samsung's cost of experimentation is lower than Apple's, which is doubly slammed by being the market leader and possessing a culture of perfection. This is letting it be the water between Apple's mass appeal cracks. Whether this is a beachhead or a place to chill until the sun comes up is uncertain.
- noahl 14y agoOn a related note, it occurred to me that Microsoft is handicapped by their culture of doing big releases and not (publicly?) iterating much in between them. The article makes it sound like Samsung iterates quickly and is very responsive, whereas both Microsoft and Apple have much longer product development cycles.
- sjtrny 14y agoInnovation isn't about saying yes to everything. It's about saying no to all but the most important things.
- neya 14y agoLike, not having the ability to use your phone's basic features without iTunes?
- trendnet 14y agoWhen was the last time you saw an iPhone?
- neya 14y agoOh, really? I'd love to see you transfer music to your phone without using iTunes. Or I'd love to see you transfer a file via bluetooth to another phone that's not an iPhone. Or..I'd love to see you install an app that wasn't released on the market without jail-breaking your phone.
- mamcx 14y ago>you transfer music to your phone without using iTunes Can be done >transfer a file via bluetooth to another phone that's not an iPhone Can't be done (AFAIK) but is possible to transfer using more normal and useful internet protocols. > install an app that wasn't released on the market without jail-breaking Can be done. I do it all the time. Can be argued that iOS not operate exactly as Android, and the opposite. Some operations are more convoluted than others (in both). However, iOS work, in average, better for the end-user than the alternatives (is very telling that the evidence in how Android is best than iOS is, mainly, in niche cases, complex operations, dev-stuff, and things that are not normal for the average user).
- lttlrck 14y agoyou're disqualified.
- Uchikoma 14y agoI loved my Apple Newton with it's stylus.
- pootch 14y agoinnovation, its great tony the tiger style. For example, MS: a completely stupid fucking file system that makes no sense. Walk past any windows users desktop and look at it covered in icons and files. MS Innovation, failure to make a file system usable. Walk past a mac users machine. No icons or files on the desktop because the filesystem works. Android, completely inconsistent reboot clone of MS Windows. Walk by an android developers desk. 60 phones on his desk. No app can be tested. Walk by an iOS developers desk. 2 phones and an iPad. Thats innovation.
- marknutter 14y agoThis is a fundamental misunderstanding about how Apple does innovation. They are far less likely to "experiment" on their user base as the author describes Samsung doing, and often their innovations are pretty incremental but very well thought out and polished. Some users appreciate Apple's more conservative approach to innovation, and others find it stifling. Low and behold, there's a market for both types of people.
- neya 14y agoTell me one thing that's so innovative about Apple, please? Suing people for rounded corners and not being able to transfer music or files without iTunes nor not being able to install any third-party apps directly without Jailbraking isn't exactly innovation. And, for the record, Apple had ripped off so many features from Android and re-labeled it as 'revolutionary features'.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- shadesandcolour 14y agoObvious troll is unbelievably obvious. Go ahead and give me something that Samsung innovated, in a vacuum, without looking at other products and without help from Google.
- neya 14y agoI am not talking on behalf of Samsung, I'm simply talking against Apple. I own HTC Android phones, they've had a multitude of features well-before Apple debuted their 'magically life-changing revolutionary' iOS 6. As for Samsung, without Google's help, I think there is a reason why they're #1 on the international display market. Do you know how many companies use Samsung's displays? Even my Sony Vaio and my Sony bravia use their displays under the hood. The display segment is where one simply cannot sustain without innovating. Samsung's leadership in displays are evidence that they can innovate alone, which is the answer to the question you've asked me. I bet the display with which you're reading HN now, uses Samsung's technology in some form or the other - That's the depth of their remarkable engineering and innovation. Can you say the same for Apple? They're just re-packagers. Someone else manufactures something for them and then they just add their logo and increase the prices by 4x, which you purchase and don't want to feel bad for, by labeling rational arguments as trolls on a public forum. Instead of blatantly labeling me as a troll, I'd love to see you provide evidence in support of Apple's 'innovation'. Don't talk about profits, just pure innovation. You'd be surprised how little you have to talk in favor of (Apple), when it comes to innovation.
- DanBC 14y agoThreads like these make me long for word filters. "XXX is an evil company!" "Not as bad as XXX, who are much worse!!" "No way, XXX are worse!!! You're just an XXX fanboy!!!!"
- nicholassmith 14y agoMan, isn't it weird that a company might be out-innovating another company? Man, isn't it weird that another OS might do things in a different way? Man, isn't it weird that a cnn contributor might have said things that will split a room and have various spheres of the tech world proclaiming "No YOUR phone is a dick"? Here's the rub, iOS has gone down a very straightened route. It's a managed, curated, locked down experience. The static icons are because Apple wants the OS out of the way as much as possible because you're not there to stare at that, you're there to fondle whatever app you want. Android has thrown much niceness in for customising, and having windowing, non-static tiles, information widgets and what not because they know that's what some consumers want. Lets all take a breath. It's all okay. Android is a great OS! So is iOS! They do different things which work better for different people. Look at it this way, having two companies making excellent operating systems, and two companies making excellent hardware can only help to get other companies to similarly up their game. For what it's worth I wouldn't say Samsung is necessarily out-innovating Apple, but they are putting things together in a very, very nice way. I see as many Samsung Android devices on my commute as I do iPhones and that's not a bad thing, but I can't think of anything that Samsung has done recently that's stood right out as a massive innovation, but I don't pay as much attention as I should.
- wheeee 14y agoThere's a typo in the headline. They misspelled "copying."