5 ms·
Every time I see Google Glass I think "Oh, cool" and then I realize that what I want/need in everyday life is de-augmented reality (i.e. just vanilla reality).
by jgrahamc 14y ago
Every time I see Google Glass I think "Oh, cool" and then I realize that what I want/need in everyday life is de-augmented reality (i.e. just vanilla reality). I've already got devices buzzing etc. to get my attention for "important thing".
The argument for things like Glass is that they will make the merging of reality and technology seamless which could have great advantages. I fear, however, that it just means I'll have a thing right in front of my face asking for my attention.
The $1B idea with Google Glass is not the technology of putting it in front of your eyes etc., it's figuring out the software that filters down what's shown to the stuff you actually want/need. I don't think we've done that successfully in other domains yet.
- jwdunne 14y agoI see these things as a natural progression. The Internet is so important that we are becoming connected tighter with each revolultion. When I first started using the Internet, it was using an unreliable 56k on a large desktop. I had to visit one spot in my house to connect. After this, I got my first laptop. This was great because now I can connect any where in my house. By that time, I had broadband do always on, faster and way more reliable. Fast forward again and I got my first smart phone. Now I can connect pretty much anywhere (given a decent signal) just by pulling my phone out of my pocket. Google Glass means I won't have to pull it out of my pocket anymore. Now my life will be constantly enhanced at every moment by great hackers, just like it has been enhanced in increasing amounts since I first touched the Internet.
- mattgreenrocks 14y agoWhere "enhanced" == abusive apps that rely on dopamine hits and fear of missing out to spur traction?
- jwdunne 14y agoNo, I cannot say my life has been enhanced by those types of applications. I'm talking stuff we take for granted like email, the web, word processing. These things have enhanced my life. The web alone opens a whole library of information and I am actually thankful because without it I'd know only a fraction of what I currently know. Similar revolutions will happen and I fully believe something like Google Glass will be the medium. Just as a thought, look at everything you use computers for now and think what it'd be like if they wasn't there? Even the most basic tasks should be considered.
- imcqueen 14y agoI also think people will be much more strict when it comes to picking "apps" for a device like Glass, or at least more strict with permissions. Just from personal experience the more capable something is of interrupting me the more selective I am with privileges.
- lloeki 14y agoWhile I can barely tolerate ads and always go for the ad-free version of an app when possible, I would mandate precisely zero ads for such a device to register as worthwhile on my radar.
- OGinparadise 14y agoGoogle Glass means I won't have to pull it out of my pocket anymore. Now my life will be constantly enhanced at every moment by great hackers, just like it has been enhanced in increasing amounts since I first touched the Internet. Try this for enhancement: shut everything off and talk to a human being, be it the local bagel shop owner or a homeless person. If I had to bet your life isn't being enhanced, it's being drained away, app by app. How many coffee cup pics must one post online? It gets boring after a while, and, imo, it's a sign of depression and a feeling of inferiority.
- tedks 14y agoI've lived my entire sentient life with a cable or faster Internet connection. I spend virtually all of my time that is not spent going out with friends, eating lunch with colleagues, or having alone time with my partner on my laptop, Xbox, or Nexus S. I am, seemingly, what you fear. I cannot think of a single reason why it would be more productive for me to talk to a homeless person instead of doing any of the things I do on computing devices on a daily basis. I don't think you can name any, beyond straw men like "you're wasting your time looking at pictures of coffee cups on the Internet." Because my life is constantly mediated by technology, I can tell you with very good precision that of the 8,760 hours in 2011, I only wasted 939 of them (and most of that was playing video games over the summer -- it's arguable that I'm not wasting time by experiencing the story of Mass Effect the same way I wouldn't be wasting my time experiencing the story of The Hunger Games, but books are more high status, so I'll give myself incentive to prefer them over video games). If uploading pictures of coffee cups to the Internet is what you do with most of your time on computers, I feel genuinely sorry for you, and I hope that you can find a better hobby. I don't think that talking to random people you run into during your day is that hobby, though. Have you tried this app ShuffleMyLife? It might give you better things to do outdoors than try to start conversations with shopkeepers.
- OGinparadise 14y agoI can tell you with very good precision that of the 8,760 hours in 2011, I only wasted 939 of them That's pretty good for a robot but you can still improve. As for me, I am a normal person, I don't need to track every freaking minute of my life or be "connected" to a million devices at any moment.
- mtgx 14y agoMaybe for you, but the trend is to become increasingly more connected. People can still choose not to use their phone 16 hours a day, and yet they do it anyway.
- eps 14y ago> Every time I see Google Glass I think... ... do I really want fragments of my life to be recorded by total strangers and then shared with God knows who? I really don't. It's a cool tech, but its social implications are far from being trivial and benign.
- judofyr 14y ago> It's a cool tech, but its social implications are far from being trivial and benign. Is there any cool tech that doesn't have difficult social implications?
- JuDue 14y agoAgreed. You only need to look at Google Play's lack of privacy to realise they see the user as a consuming resource. At least Apple treats you more like the owner of your purchase, rather than something to drive ads with data.
- aaronbasssett 14y agoSo I take it you never go outside? CCTV is already omnipresent. I'm not saying I agree with it, just that there are larger surveillance battles to be fought.
- yareally 14y agoSince you live in the UK[1], I would guess CCTV would be everywhere. However, not every country is covered with CCTV (yet). That will probably change in the future though. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closed-circuit_television#Uses http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closed-circuit_television#Uses
- eps 14y agoDon't substitute the issue. There are no CCTVs at workplace, at the parties and in the subway carriages. And no CCTVs are sharing out to the public. And, no, they are not "omnipresent".
- potatolicious 14y agoMost CCTV cameras are private and not monitored. You install them and have them record on a loop - old data is automatically erased to make room for new data. When something bad happens (an accident, a robbery, etc) recording is stopped and the existing data is handed over to relevant parties. This is far less problematic than an omnipresent, monitored, shared, catalogued and indexed in perpetuity, video system.
- 7952 14y agoIt does seem to rely heavily on picking at low hanging fruit. Flight times are important if you are in an airport, but its hardly life changing. My hunch is that it will be made by a hundred thousand small niche uses rather than a single billion dollar idea. This could be completely transcendent, and maybe needs to be to cut through the sensible aversion to this kind of tech.
- DrDreams 14y agoI agree. I think, like cell phones, they will add more value in specific occupations, like package deliveries/warehouses, than everyday life. Once enough niche apps are developed and people start to feel the need to bring those apps into everyday life, then people will use them.
- jgrahamc 14y agoFlight times at the airport are a great example. I don't need to know the time of my flight, but I do need to know if it's been delayed or if the gate changes. I don't need to know those things I already know them in some other way.
- 7952 14y agoBut the flight example could work just as well or better with text messages from the airline. Your example is just a more annoying way of displaying notifications.
- nthj 14y agoI was about to disagree with you, but I realized the real problem I wanted to address was the importance of context. Text messages from an airline aren't great because by default they have the same "ding" as random jokes and "hey what's up." messages. But Google Glasses could easily start having the exact same problem. We need software to be trained with more intelligent context awareness — hey, Nathaniel put his phone on silent, but he is at the airport and here is a notification about a delayed flight, so the phone should vibrate a little bit to make sure he sees it. We're getting better at this, as an industry: I walk into the Apple Store, it asks me to check into my genius appointment. If I walk into the movie theater, my phone pulls up my ticket as a QR code. But we still have a long way to go, and I think it's a far more interesting and important problem than whether the information shows up on my glasses or my phone.
- dannyr 14y agoIf you talk to the members of the Google Glass Team, they actually tell you that the device is not to augment reality at all. Google Glass augmenting reality was coined by the press. That should give you an idea where Google is heading with this product.
- minwcnt5 14y ago> I've already got devices buzzing etc. to get my attention for "important thing". Isn't that the point though? Glass should require far less of your attention than these devices because it eliminates the need to reach into your pocket, pull it out (your device that is), swiping/unlocking, having to look down, needing a free hand or two, etc. Even something as simple as being able to scroll through my email/G+/twitter/IM hands free would be revolutionary for me and make them well worth wearing, as long as there's a gesture or gyroscope or subvocalization input mode of some sort so I don't need to give it constant voice/touch commands. It'd be well worth looking like an idiot nodding every few seconds or whatever.
- snowwrestler 14y agoHumans can walk and talk at the same time. We cannot walk and read at the same time. We can drive and talk at the same time. We cannot drive and read at the same time. To me the conclusion is obvious: pervasive wearable computing must talk to us, not show us things, to be useful. More specifically it must talk with us--understand what we want, when we want it, and give it to us. I agree with you that the hardware is nothing compared to the complexity of the decision-making software. I think it is probably a multi-trillion-dollar opportunity, but it's so hard that no one company will solve it suddenly enough to corner the market.
- piyush_soni 14y agoUh. What about superimposed maps on roads for example? What about product information just being there when you look at that in the super market (and whether it's cheaper somewhere on the internet). Or its nutrition information/health hazards etc. ! There are thousands of applications of pervasive wearable devices which 'shows us things'.
- snowwrestler 14y agoIf you superimpose a map on a road, you can't see the road anymore because the map gets in the way.
- piyush_soni 14y agoYou really think so? Which class you are studying in?