4 ms·
WTF. Libertarianism is like some grumpy religion, people are always trying to bring it up even when it doesn't fit. And it's so wrong about how the real world
by guelo 14y ago
WTF. Libertarianism is like some grumpy religion, people are always trying to bring it up even when it doesn't fit.
And it's so wrong about how the real world works. If a community doesn't have a school the first thing that normally happens is they form a government and elect a school board to figure how to build and fund it. Same with a fire department, even with volunteers there are a lot of expenses that need to be paid by the town. Even the sports team is normally brought to a town via the work of politicians.
What these government-haters don't understand is that government IS the community. It's how a community comes together to get things done.
- bdunbar 14y ago"What these government-haters" Hi. libertarian here. I don't hate government. Government is probably a necessary evil. I hate obnoxious, inefficient, bug-ridden, corrupt, expensive, government. I hate government that says one thing to get elected and then promptly does another. I hate government that ostensibly is an extension of the will of the people and then acts against their expressed wishes. But I'm not grumpy about it.
- guelo 14y agoEverybody wants well-run government, that's not libertarianism. Libertarians want less government, not better government.
- bdunbar 14y agoI may have skipped over some steps in my thinking. But yes, a small government with few to little power is what we need.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoYes, because big business doesn't have enough power yet already. That's who would step in. You would reduce the size of government and corporations would just fill the power vacuum. But we all know who funds the Libertarian party anyway - corporations or billionaires (who own corporations).
- elliottkember 14y agoWhile I have no issues with these arguments or their intent, I feel like this is not the forum for such a discussion. There are much better venues for political discourse than HN - let's keep it about tech.
- n3rdy 14y ago> Yes, because big business doesn't have enough power yet already. > That's who would step in. You would reduce the size of government and corporations would just fill the power vacuum. Because that hasn't happened already, even with a huge government. > But we all know who funds the Libertarian party anyway - corporations or billionaires (who own corporations). Corporations are actually government entities. One of those handy things that help businesses get big enough to manipulate governments. A business doesn't just apply as a corporation for tax benefits, it also does so for the limited liability. So when they unwittingly contaminate your property, or accidentally poison you with rancid meat, the owner of the corporation won't have to sell their house to settle the lawsuits that follow their companies negligence. So that government you think protects you from big business, passes the risks that business owner would normally have to take upon himself, onto you.
- n3rdy 14y agoHi. Anarchist here, I do hate government. Government in my opinion is an unnecessary tragedy that has befallen humanity and murdered close to 1 billion people. This is by far the most intelligent community I have come across in all my internet travels, and if there is any group of people who can think of a way for society to run peacefully, it is this community. Any problem we have as a society that people currently point to government as a solution, can be solved without resorting to threatening everyone with police action.
- chrisbennet 14y agoIt worked in that utopia called Somalia after all. :-)
- n3rdy 14y agoThe non-sharia controlled parts have been better off than they were with their previous government. Their air travel industry is even profitable, more than we can say. I'd say that's a lot more than you could ask for considering the exploitation of the region.
- jiggy2011 14y agoKinda sucks if you do live a sharia controlled part then. Here in the UK there are groups who would love to annex of chunks of the country as sharia zones but thankfully the law prevents this.
- bdunbar 14y agoThat was 'libertarian' with a small 'l'. I'm not dogmatic: if anarchy can work, I'm all for it.
- monkeypizza 14y agoThanks for the comment. I was more thinking about how things worked from say 1500 to 1800 in the US. During that time, a lot of the things that originate with government in simcity would have been done independently. i.e. religious schools would be started by local enclaves (sometimes with organizational help of government, which they controlled due to being dominant in that area, but not originated from it). In the US at least, land use was pretty free for most of that time, no zoning. Look at the institutions within a gold rush town, for example - although there was a government, they couldn't control much, the people came first and built lots of infrastructure before there ever was a sheriff or mayor. Rollicking, fast-developing cities from that era weren't restrained by zoning laws, and they developed in interesting (not always good) ways. It is interesting to realize that most of the current buildings in the US major cities would actually be illegal under the current law for new buildings. Rather than from libertarianism, my ideas for this came from a couple books about city planning I've read recently, "The Power Broker", and "The Death and Life of Great American Cities". Neither one is really libertarian, but rather look at how government power can be used or misused in cities. The latter one particularly is not at all libertarian, and is a strong advocate of government intervention into neighborhood design - but, lays out a smarter way it should be done, based on the author's understanding of the way cities work. Simcity seems to be designed by someone influenced by the ideas criticized in "death and life" - i.e. very strong zoning laws, top-down control and predetermination for how things will work in every neighborhood, high value placed on "open space" without consideration of usage patterns etc.
- n3rdy 14y ago> What these government-haters don't understand is that government IS the community. It's how a community comes together to get things done. Government is the monopoly on force used to enforce a communities policies. You do not need to threaten people with violence to get things done. If you are not threatening people with violence to get things done, if all participation is voluntary, then you are not using a government to get things done.