3 ms·
I blame Eric Raymond and to a lesser extent Dave Winer for bringing this kind of schlock writing onto the Internet. Raymond is the original perpetrator of the "
by mindcrime 14y ago
I blame Eric Raymond and to a lesser extent Dave Winer for bringing this kind of schlock writing onto the Internet. Raymond is the original perpetrator of the "what is a hacker?" essay, in which you quickly begin to understand that a hacker is someone who resembles Eric Raymond
Sounds like a pretty weak criticism to me. We all reflect our own biases and opinions in our writings, surely? If pg wrote "how to be a hacker" wouldn't you wind up with something suggesting that hackers should be like pg? If rtm wrote "how to be a hacker" do you think it wouldn't wind up reflecting a bias towards his mindsets and attitudes? If onan_barbarian wrote "how to be a hacker" would it not create an argument for hackers being much like onan_barbarian?
If esr's essay is factually incorrect or misleading or damaging in some fashion, then I'd encourage anyone to criticize it for that, rather than just slamming the man for writing it.
- onan_barbarian 14y agoI suspect you're missing his point, possibly wilfully. Regardless of whether you agree with it or not, his criticism is that the content of the "how to be a hacker" essay in question is almost nothing more than thinly veiled self-description.
- mindcrime 14y agoI suspect you're missing his point No, I get the point, I just saying he's wrong.
- Confusion 14y agoIt's perfectly possible to write from your experience, while consciously trying to generalize, keeping an eye out for biases. As a (self proclaimed) figurehead of a movement, you may even be expected to do so. Esr has certainly not done that, which most clearly shows in the 'points for style' section of his essay. I'm into martial arts myself, but suggesting that as a 'point for style' is ludicrous. Combine it with an incentive to go 'pistol shooting' and I actually think it is offensive.
- mindcrime 14y agoIt sounds like you're picking nits to me. You're talking about two points, in what is hardly the core of the essay, and using that to justify a broad criticism of the whole essay? Look, I disagree with esr on more than a few things myself. But this essay strikes me as a fairly reasonable introduction to a number of activities and mindsets that a would-be hacker would want to cultivate. And it's not like he is saying "This is the only route to becoming a hacker". I also don't understand your thing about finding the reference to pistol shooting "offensive". I can understand if you're an anti-gunner or whatever and don't like guns, but the simple facts are that millions of people enjoy going to the range and shooting their pistols. We're talking about something that is legal (with some caveats), safe, fun, and has positive personal benefits... it's not like he suggested going out and watching kiddie-porn or stealing food from starving children.