12 ms·
Sigh. Now change university (or plumber) to comic strip writer. Why does he still get money every time his comic strip is sold? Shouldn't he get money just once
by ars 18y ago
Sigh. Now change university (or plumber) to comic strip writer. Why does he still get money every time his comic strip is sold? Shouldn't he get money just once? The publisher pays him a flat fee, and done.
The university donation is charity. But I don't see him asking, why do people give to charity.
Now change plumber to doctor - the rich support the doctor and the poor give what they can. Sound reasonable? It should - it was the typical model for a good part of history. So why is doctor different from plumber?
- DanielBMarkham 18y ago<friendly sarcasm> Now substitute me for doctor. Shouldn't people give me money when they can for the good that I do for society? Why am I any different than the doctor? Is the guy who prescribes medicine that much better than the guy who writes code to manage the prescription? From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs, right? </friendly sarcasm>
- ars 18y agoWhy be sarcastic? You are not different. Except that these days we don't fund many things that way. But it wasn't always so, in the past if you were not a patron of the arts (which also meant science), you were nobody. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patronage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patronage Effectively that was a way of funding exactly the type of thing you describe - you just had to explain how what you did helped society. For example look up the Balmis Expedition, which was funded by the King of Spain. I'm trying to say, it's not really so strange to fund things that way, it's just that today it's limited to certain types of institutions/programs. The main reason it's not as common these days is the flattening of the income curve. You don't have such extremes of wealth and poverty. People can usually afford the things they need. But when they can't, this type of funding does come into play. This explains why expensive universities get donations, but cheaper ones don't.