3 ms·
It's interesting to note that much of the success of large US universities, compared to their European counterparts, has been driven by the fact that American a
by cperciva 18y ago
It's interesting to note that much of the success of large US universities, compared to their European counterparts, has been driven by the fact that American alumni are far more generous than European alumni. Only about 10% of Oxford alumni make donations to the university, while most US universities have donation rates exceeding 50% -- and Oxford and Cambridge are doing considerably better than their continental counterparts.
Whether this is due to US universities being more aggressive in soliciting donations (they are), more willing to allow admissions decisions to be influenced by donations (they are), or simply due to US alumni having more money to throw around (the US has a higher income gap between degree and non-degree holders than Europe) isn't clear; but whatever is causing this difference in donations, it has huge consequences.
- troels 18y agoWithout actually knowing anything about it, I would venture to guess that European universities get a lot more funding from the state than American universities do.
- cperciva 18y agoIt depends how you measure it. European universities get far more money from governments as fixed operating grants; but US universities slice money out of research grants (they call it "overhead") and redirect it to their operating budgets.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoQuite right. Remember, when a politician proposes $N for science, remember that he actually means 50% of $N as subsidies for universities, and 50% of $N for science. (Assuming of course that the science is done by university professors. )
- anamax 18y agoGovt funding doesn't explain why even public universities in the US get more private support.
- Luc 18y agoMy university education was free (to me) aside from a trivially small yearly fee. It's this way for all students in my small Western European nation. The universities I attended received money from the state for each student. So why should I donate to them (not that I have ever been asked to)? The more students, the better, and their economic background doesn't matter.
- jacoblyles 18y agoThe US has a stronger voluntary private civic culture. I seem to recall that the US has the highest charitable giving rate in the world. However, with the government raising taxes on charitable donations and expanding social services to match the European model, we may see our civic culture whither to match theirs, too (the argument of Albert Jay Nock).