3 ms·
Indeed. The US private sector and the US federal government EACH spend more per capita on health care than the UK does. And yet we rank behind the UK on virtu
by btilly 14y ago
Indeed. The US private sector and the US federal government EACH spend more per capita on health care than the UK does. And yet we rank behind the UK on virtually every health statistic that they bother to track.
In 1993 Republicans did an interesting analysis. They found that Clinton's health care plan would work, and would be popular. If it passed, they believed that Republicans would be losing national elections for a generation. But they also figured out that if they derailed it, then they could turn fears about it into a potent election issue. They did, and it was. They tried the same thing with Obama's plan. Whether the other half of their prediction comes true is yet to be decided.
For the actual Republican analysis from 1993, see http://delong.typepad.com/egregious_moderation/2009/03/william-kristol-defeating-president-clintons-health-care-proposal.html http://delong.typepad.com/egregious_moderation/2009/03/willi....
- kevinskii 14y ago> "They found that Clinton's health care plan would work..." They found nothing of the sort. Did you even bother to read their analysis at your link? You can disagree with someone without misrepresenting their motives.
- cpleppert 14y agoYou are exactly right and often times the ability to derail a reform plan in the legislature costs it support not only by seemingly discrediting it in the political process but also forcing reform advocates to support a concrete bill that has real consequences while opponents don't need to offer anything and can attack consequences of the bill passing out of context. No one is sure it will pass, so invariably some members waver and the bill is watered down to guarantee support, at which point it becomes compromised and rather ineffective which once again discredits reform. Its interesting in the post-1945 election in the UK very few voters strongly supported the NHS but once it passed it developed bipartisan support. The chances of a party taking every house of congress a supermajority in the senate and the presidency to have the ability to move legislation is incredibly small in our system as compared to a parliamentary one. I'm not suggesting that our system is always worse but in this instance it certainly is.
- gruseom 14y agoNot only that, but as Dean Baker never tires of pointing out, if the US only spent as much as other rich countries do on health care (countries that get better health outcomes), it would have huge budget surpluses rather than deficits.