7 ms·
Some excerpts: He was a charming, damaged, charismatic, fiercely intelligent, dissolute individual, who lived entirely on his own terms. As a professional gamb
by danso 14y ago
Some excerpts:
He was a charming, damaged, charismatic, fiercely intelligent, dissolute individual, who lived entirely on his own terms. As a professional gambler, it is unlikely he paid much if any tax in 37 years. He had no will, no funeral plan. He never did fill out the forms necessary to vote in the last election, or the one before that, as I discovered. He just hated forms. I could sympathise. Had he stayed in the US, it is – how you say – dollars to doughnuts he wouldn’t have got it together to fill out the forms, and would have had no health insurance. He considered the US system “absolutely unmanageable”.
However long this goes on for, they'll continue throwing resources at this individual and never show a single sheet of figures to any of his relatives. Not because they'll get anything back, but because this is what the NHS does. It’s free care for throat cancer sufferers who only gave up smoking four years afterwards, for drinkers who were told 35 years ago that if they didn’t quit drinking they’d die. Free care for American immigrants, for jerks and gents. Free care for parents whether they showed up or not. Free care for guys who tried to try. Free care for the only father I will ever have.
So here comes the TANSTAAFL argument: I don't think anyone argues that what the OP describes is a "bad thing"...in fact, I think it's probably the dream scenario that people optimistically assume is the case before they have their first encounter with an emergency room.
But the reason why it doesn't happen is because of cost, plain and simple. And to be concerned about cost is not just the domain of greedy insurers and fat cat cost cutters, but of reasonable people who understand that preventive care is less dramatic than end-of-life care, but is surely as deserving of resources and attention. And both types of care rely on the same limited pot of funding.
It's easy to be emotionally invested in the personal case of a man who is lucky enough to have a loved one so eloquent with words. But what about the hundreds, thousands of routine cases that are treated by NHS with a protocol governed by cost limitations, limitations that will inevitably be imposed by the decision to give blue-chip treatment to the untreatable?
These routine cases don't pull at the heart strings because it is the nature of the human mind not to realize/dwell on how an exam/procedure not scheduled two years ago is the main factor in the chronic disease one suffers today. And yet these people are just as deserving of optimal treatment as OP's Bill. The way that OP judges the value of healthcare, though, means that the Bill's will get a greater share of a finite set of resources. Is this really the way an optimal healthcare system should work?
This is not to say that the U.S. or any other system is currently better than the NHS. It's just to point out that fashion in which the OP (positively) judges the NHS is susceptible to being ignorant of the problems that occur earlier in the pipeline of health.
- ahi 14y agoThe problem with the TANSTAAFL argument in this case is that the NHS is far cheaper than the American alternative. It is also far superior at providing preventative care than the American alternative.
- danso 14y agoJust for the record, I'm not saying NHS is worse than American healthcare. I'm just stating that its possible, in a hypothetical system, in which an efficient and fair allocation of resources will bring about end-of-life care scenarios that are less ideal than what the OP describes. And that its also possible that ideal end-of-life care will end up hurting others (through a disproportionate allocation of resources) and doing so in a way that is hard to dramatize (until it's too late). This is a tension that keeps effective health care reform from moving forward, but it's still a tension that should weigh as heavily in a debate as an emotional appeal.
- jgrahamc 14y agoAs an example of preventive care offered by the NHS. I am registered with a local GP who I hardly ever see (because I don't need to). Two years ago I received an SMS message from them because of my age (over 40) to come in for the NHS Health Check (http://www.nhs.uk/Planners/NHSHealthCheck/Pages/NHSHealthCheck.aspx http://www.nhs.uk/Planners/NHSHealthCheck/Pages/NHSHealthChe...). The test involved a bunch of basics (weight, exercise, blood pressure, etc.) and two blood tests (for cholesterol and blood sugar level). They will repeat this every five years. I do not think the NHS is the greatest possible system (in fact, I preferred the French system when I lived there), but by many measures it is good.
- btilly 14y agoIndeed. The US private sector and the US federal government EACH spend more per capita on health care than the UK does. And yet we rank behind the UK on virtually every health statistic that they bother to track. In 1993 Republicans did an interesting analysis. They found that Clinton's health care plan would work, and would be popular. If it passed, they believed that Republicans would be losing national elections for a generation. But they also figured out that if they derailed it, then they could turn fears about it into a potent election issue. They did, and it was. They tried the same thing with Obama's plan. Whether the other half of their prediction comes true is yet to be decided. For the actual Republican analysis from 1993, see http://delong.typepad.com/egregious_moderation/2009/03/william-kristol-defeating-president-clintons-health-care-proposal.html http://delong.typepad.com/egregious_moderation/2009/03/willi....