3 ms·
You know, I'm thinking about this You cannot motivate people with fear, at least not with fear alone So, I'm thinking a military action is riskier to NK than
by raverbashing 14y ago
You know, I'm thinking about this
You cannot motivate people with fear, at least not with fear alone
So, I'm thinking a military action is riskier to NK than it is to SK
SK will suffer causalities, sure, but I don't trust that a country, even militarized in abundance, without any meaningful social/economical structure can produce anything more than a fireworks show (even with decades old military technology from other countries).
And of course being obliterated in sequence.
- thesis 14y agoI think the big question is what will China do if North Korea is attacked. Sure they have been against DPRK's actions lately.. but at crunch time what happens?
- pm90 14y agoApart from providing assistance, I don't think the Chinese would actively take part in any war started by DPRK. Even in the Korean war, they entered the war only after combined US-ROK forces crossed the Yalu river.
- tomjen3 14y agoEither China invades or they let the rest of the world do as they want. China won't help NK, why should they? Nothing to gain by going to war with the west, everything to gain by trading with them.
- kiba 14y agoCan't they lob a nuclear weapon and destroy Seoul(not to mention artillery aimed squarely at Seoul)? That would be pretty devastating to South Korea.
- rza 14y agoI doubt North Korea has the capacity to mount a nuclear warhead on a missile or artillery shell. If they tried to drop it with a bomber it would surely be shot down. Yes they could devastate Seoul with artillery, but the question here is why would they do that and what would they have to gain from it. The only thing sure to happen from such an action would be full-scale war, and the subsequent collapse of the North Korean regime. Unlike the first Korean War, the Chinese are not likely to be on their side, as this time around, China is much more integrated into the international stage (read depends much more on international trade and stable relations) and China has more to gain by siding with UN forces. Of course in the aftermath of such a war, China would still want a North Korean state friendly to the Chinese government, but I doubt they would go so far as to go to war with UN forces to achieve this. Most likely they would support military action to depose the current regime, but not a complete takeover of North Korea by the UN (not so unlike the last Korean War).
- stcredzero 14y agoAll they'd need is one suicide pilot flying at treetop height to span a gap of 35 miles.
- rza 14y agoThe Korean DMZ is the most heavily militarized border in the world, I'm sure they've taken into account such possibilities. Not to mention the difficulty for North Korea to fit a nuclear warhead with any sort of meaningful yield on a small aircraft.
- raverbashing 14y agoAnd navigating to Seoul (I don't think NKs planes have GPS, do they?), not to mention terrain issues, detection by radars, etc And making the bomb work (and no, a static setup is different than putting everything in a package) Worse case it goes off over NK, or it's dropped and it doesn't go off, or goes off when hitting the ground
- stcredzero 14y ago> I don't think NKs planes have GPS, do they? They couldn't buy something off the shelf for private aviation? Also, Seoul is pretty huge. Hitting it by dead reckoning or terrain navigation over 35 miles shouldn't be an issue.
- stcredzero 14y agoYou could sacrifice most of the range to fit the bomb. A large external pod would be feasible. (This was how the B-58 Hustler carried a bomb.) Does the Koean Air Force fly CAP 24/7?
- stcredzero 14y agoThe aftermath would be devastating to them. The US and UN would invade. The situation would be a huge pain in the ass for China.
- jug6ernaut 14y agoThe last thing NK wants to do is a military action, why do you think they do all these tests and smoke and mirrors? They are provocative but can be talked down to what they want. They are all means to an end. If they had any kind of military action the full force of the UN would come down on them, that is the last thing they want. Oh and yes you can motivate people with fear alone. History is riddled with instances of this.
- raverbashing 14y ago>> Oh and yes you can motivate people with fear alone. History is riddled with instances of this. Oh, I'm sure you can. What I mean is that it may be not the most efficient way of reaching your goal. But yeah, there are a lot of cases where this works.
- henrikschroder 14y agoThe problem is that Seoul lies within artillery range of North Korea, and you can't really defend against that, because it will take time to destroy all the artillery, and in the meantime Seoul is shelled to pieces. South Korea could easily invade North Korea and defeat it, but the civilian casualties would be enormous unless you can figure out a way to protect Seoul. Complicating the matter is the fact that China is very pleased not having to share a border with South Korea, which they essentially view as an extension of the US. This was the whole point of the Korean war, after all.
- white_devil 14y ago> You cannot motivate people with fear, at least not with fear alone Fear is exactly what has kept North-Korea going for ages.