4 ms·
Why is 3D printing a gun any different to making one with machining tools? Surely the same laws should apply, and this is just an advancement of home-manufactur
by jstanley 14y ago
Why is 3D printing a gun any different to making one with machining tools? Surely the same laws should apply, and this is just an advancement of home-manufacturing technology that has no real involvement with gun laws.
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoMost people overhyping this think 3D printing would make it as simple as clicking a button, which it is most definitely not.
- kale 14y agoI use SLA 3D printing almost weekly for rapid prototyping (in the past I've used powder sintered 3D printing as well). If you can find the proper CAD file (I use STEP, or IGES), it can be made. If those plans were distributed on P2P, it would be as simple as importing the files, orient the build, and then press a button, then assemble after the run.
- damoncali 14y agoBut it could be. That is what has people all riled up.
- kabdib 14y agoIt's relatively easy to manufacture most of an AK-47 using machines that are affordable and that fit in a garage (the exception being rifled barrels, but those are relatively easy to find). In the US, it's also perfectly legal, as long as the firearm is not capable of automatic fire. If you have a CNC mill, you can make your own AR-15 (again, you'll probably have to buy a barrel). The "OMG people will print guns" stuff is just hysteria and grandstanding.
- kale 14y agoEven with CNC programming, a person has to have skills to properly mount and orient the work (center if on a CNC lathe, zero the coordinate system if on a mill), machine, and assemble. It takes decent skill to make a firearm with conventional machining. The concern (I'm not saying it's a founded concern) is that 3D printing would allow unskilled folks to download increasingly complex plans and implement them with little skill. The pool of people with good CNC machining skills (and access to at least $10K worth of very heavy equipment) is probably less than the pool of people with $5K spare cash (ballparking what a future 3D printer might cost) and only basic mechanical skills.
- potatolicious 14y agoExcept, as brought up elsewhere in the thread - the present state of 3D printing (and the state in the foreseeable future) also require substantial personal skill to print a weapon. The prospect of an unskilled individual loading a file in a program, hitting "print", and retrieving a usable gun from the other end, is not at all realistic. I still don't see what distinguishes this from good old gunsmithing laws/issues.
- damoncali 14y agoYou're overstating the ease with which you can create a rifle with machine tools. While it can be done, it is both time consuming and very difficult to do in a home shop, or even a proper shop. If 3D printers could print materials with the appropriate structural characteristics (a huge if), it would be much easier. I have serious doubts about that happening in my lifetime. It's quite a trick to go from printing ABS to printing hardened steel.
- kabdib 14y agoMy point isn't that it's a simple job. My point is that it's legal today, and that you /can/ do it. A beginner with a 20 ton press and some other simple tools could probably bend an AK blank and have a rifle in a week or so. I don't know what's involved in making the blank (probably a way to cut sheet steel and a jig for drilling accurate holes). Fiddly bits (springs and such) are available in kits; these are tough to make yourself, but people do. There's a video of gun shops in Pakistan making perfectly servicable rifles under extremely primitive conditions. Of course, the folks doing this have a lot of experience. Sure, printing would make it easier. No, the current 3D printer materials will not work. On the other hand, the AK is designed so that the receiver doesn't need to be uber strong, and we might not be /that/ far from the required material strength for everything except the barrel.
- talmand 14y agoYou seem to be assuming that the term rifle always implies something complicated like an AR-15 or AK. The most likely reason someone would go about creating a rifle in their garage due to an oppressive government is because most likely all guns have been banned and confiscated. In that situation, the ability to create a simple bolt-action rifle would be of immense value to anyone fighting the oppressive government. For that matter, a good shotgun that doesn't require rifling is better than nothing. Another option is to make smooth-bore musket types, in the past they were accurate up to 100 yards or so. Considering that in the past rifles were created by hand with simple tools, as compared to today's technology, I don't find it hard to believe that a small group of dedicated people can figure out how to make somewhat quality firearms in their garage with modern tools. This talk of people making something like an AR-15 from a printer anytime soon is just someone that's looking for something political out of it, a scare the populace tactic.