3 ms·
Note that the first comment misses an important point that is clear in the briefs: He did not go out and deliberately buy 2nd generation roundup ready seeds. H
by DannyBee 14y ago
Note that the first comment misses an important point that is clear in the briefs:
He did not go out and deliberately buy 2nd generation roundup ready seeds.
He went out and deliberately bought 2nd generation commodity seeds. Simply because of market penetration, most of the seeds ended up being roundup ready seeds.
He discovered this because he sprayed them with Roundup.
I can't think of a more clear case of patent exhaustion.
They would have to remove patent exhaustion from self-replicating technologies to make this not a clear case.
Note 2 things:
1. On average, the supreme court doesn't take cases to uphold them (there is no point in doing so). There were at least 4 votes of justices who thought it was worth hearing the case.
2. Monsanto has a very simple solution: contracts with farmers.