8 ms·
US Supreme Court to Hear Monsanto Seed Patent Case
- untothebreach 14y agoAnyone else getting a ssl warning?
- xutopia 14y agoI'm not.
- whatshisface 14y agoCheck your computer's date/time, that has been the cause of false ssl negatives for me in the past.
- raimondious 14y agoMixed secure/insecure causes the page to display without any CSS for me.
- dchest 14y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5195676 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5195676
- mjn 14y agoThanks for the link. The first comment on that version of the discussion is informative, and gets to the heart of the case, which is somewhat more specific than a lot of the commentary (though other issues are clearly implicated). The core of it is whether the Supreme Court will read the patent-exhaustion doctrine narrowly or broadly. The traditional application of patent exhaustion allows you to combine a patented part with other standard equipment, if the patented part was purchased legally. So, for example, you can buy a CPU and then assemble it with other electronic components into a larger device, without getting a second patent license for the larger device. The farmer here is arguing that buying a seed and having it reproduce should fall under patent exhaustion, because growing seeds and having them produce more seeds is something that, in farming, happens routinely by just adding "standard equipment" such as soil, fertilizer, and water. Therefore no second license should be needed for continued routine use of the legitimately purchased initial product. Buying a license to the seed should imply, by patent exhaustion, the regular use of the seed for all things seeds are normally expected to do, including planting them and harvesting their offspring. The counter-argument is that in the CPU example the original purchased part is still enclosed in the larger device, whereas in the seed case the offspring seeds are not a superset of the original seed, so the result is actually a copy, more like duplicating the CPU (which would need a new license). The troublesome part with making the analogy work either way is that the seed duplicated itself as part of its normal functioning, which CPUs don't normally do. Viewed that way, the case has interesting implications for the future patent situation around self-replicating robots.
- DannyBee 14y agoNote that the first comment misses an important point that is clear in the briefs: He did not go out and deliberately buy 2nd generation roundup ready seeds. He went out and deliberately bought 2nd generation commodity seeds. Simply because of market penetration, most of the seeds ended up being roundup ready seeds. He discovered this because he sprayed them with Roundup. I can't think of a more clear case of patent exhaustion. They would have to remove patent exhaustion from self-replicating technologies to make this not a clear case. Note 2 things: 1. On average, the supreme court doesn't take cases to uphold them (there is no point in doing so). There were at least 4 votes of justices who thought it was worth hearing the case. 2. Monsanto has a very simple solution: contracts with farmers.
- speeder 14y agoPersonally I believe that patenting genes in first place is overall a bad idea... But yet, I see the importance of biotechnology, specially because I believe bioengineering might be useful, actually using biological things to make constructs, like living buildings, vehicles, batteries, and that sort of things. On this case, I hope monsanto loses. Because they winning would set a too dangerous precedent. Yet, they losing, would not damage biotech too much, you could always invent biotechnology that cannot be easily reproduced. My father is friend of a guy that invented a special mix of microbial and fungal life that improve composting technology in a very interesting manner, and for him, there is no need to make crazy contracts about people not reproducing what he sells, because he ships them in a way that you can use the living product on your composting solution, but you cannot replicate the product (with enough effort, you CAN replicate it, but the replica is imperfect and the performance is not the same, so if you want 100% of performance, you must buy more of it), it is actually very clever and interesting. This sort of thing, I would think it is maybe good. But using legal means to prevent normal biological behaviour from happening, it is very bad idea, and quite dangerous in what sort of havoc it might unleash.
- kvb 14y agoThat's a lot easier when you're not trying to improve edible seeds (soybeans, corn, etc.). Although as I understand it, Monsanto also developed techniques for making the seeds infertile, but got so much pubic backlash that they never deployed the technology. It seems to me that they're in a bit of a bind, where whatever they do will be perceived as "evil" (perhaps due to previous bad behavior on their part).
- dionidium 14y agoThis is exactly right. There are two ways that Monsanto can sustain their business. One is technological and the other relies on the courts. Monsanto is called evil, either way, often by people who just get some vague icky feeling about GMOs, even if they understand very little about the business or the technology.
- 14y ago
- beedogs 14y agoWhy do I get the feeling SCOTUS will render a terrible decision in this case?
- ars 14y agoDefine "terrible". Or is terrible anything you disagree with?
- rayiner 14y agoBecause you haven't read a SCOTUS opinion recently except the bits and pieces of Citizens United you saw on HuffPo?
- DannyBee 14y agoAs mentioned, the supreme court doesn't really take cases to uphold them. Granting cert means at least 4 justices wanted to hear the case, presumably to reverse it (it could be that they they really wanted to say something about it, but that seems like it would not really apply in this case). Monsanto did not expect the supremes to take this case.
- btilly 14y agoIf you want to be optimistic, you might look at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_for_Molecular_Pathology_v._Myriad_Genetics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_for_Molecular_Patho... and hope that some of them want to get a broad ruling on the patentability of genes.
- einhverfr 14y agoMyriad's an interesting case. I suspect their lawyers have their work cut out for them given Prometheus v. Mayo (recently decided). I don't see how Myriad's patents can survive Prometheus.
- DannyBee 14y agoAfter reading the argument transcripts for the Monsanto case, i'm not optimistic. I'm a supreme court bar member, so my plan was to listen to Myriad in person.
- wglb 14y agoSo tptacek--will you be testifying there?
- deepGem 14y agoMonsanto uses the terminator gene technology to stop the seed replication beyond first generation. So why would they fight to patent a seed. If they want farmers not to use the seed beyond the first generation, they've already done it. What they are now trying to do is to put a 'blanket patent law' that'll prevent farmers from buying seeds from anyone else for any purpose whatsoever. It's like me having to pay royalty to Apple for buying a used macbook :). Also, the analogy to software piracy given in the article is totally flawed. Software is written so that it doesn't self replicate (unless it's a virus), however an organism's default behaviour is to self replicate. Isn't this such a simple argument to win ?
- dionidium 14y agoMonsanto uses the terminator gene technology to stop the seed replication beyond first generation. No, they don't [0]: Because some stakeholders expressed concerns that this technology might lead to dependence for small farmers, Monsanto Company, an agricultural products company and the world's biggest seed supplier, pledged not to commercialize the technology in 1999.[2] Customers who buy patented transgenic seeds from Monsanto must sign a contract not to save or sell the seeds from their harvest,[3] which preempts the need for a "terminator gene". Also, regarding this: It's like me having to pay royalty to Apple for buying a used macbook :). No, this is like your Macbook being able to make copies of itself, so that after you buy one, you've got a new copy every year for the rest of your life. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_use_restriction_technology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_use_restriction_technol...
- bhickey 14y agoNo, this is like your Macbook being able to make copies of itself, so that after you buy one, you've got a new copy every year for the rest of your life. The degree to which a business model is ill-conceived imparts no duty to other actors.
- dionidium 14y agoThis is one of those things that sounds sort of clever but is obviously just nonsense. Lots of things are possible that we limit or prohibit because it's desirable that we do so. If the creation of this sort of tech is desirable -- and I'd argue that the market really, really wants this stuff -- then there's nothing weird about creating legal mechanisms that support it.
- kochb 14y ago"Mr. Bowman said that before his case, Vernon Hugh Bowman v. Monsanto, 11-796, was taken pro bono..., he had spent $31,000 on legal fees and handled much of the legal research himself, using a computer at the library because he does not own one." There's a real farmer for you. Don't know anything about law? Doesn't matter, can't be too hard, I'll figure it out.
- mtgx 14y agoMicrosoft is supporting Monsanto here? Seriously? If they are supporting this, which seems to me that it has very little to do with them (to say the least) then we should expect Microsoft to fight hard against any sort of meaningful reform of the patent system. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130218/02022922012/supreme-court-set-to-hear-case-whether-not-planting-legally-purchased-seeds-infringe-monsanto-patent.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130218/02022922012/supre...
- ubernostrum 14y agoMicrosoft cares, and the Business Software Alliance cares, because one potential impact of the ruling would be that the license agreements which come with basically all proprietary software would be rendered null with respect to their restrictions on copying (the argument that IP protection is exhausted at sale of a seed can easily extend to the idea that it expires at sale of a piece of software). See SCOTUSblog for more: http://www.scotusblog.com/2013/02/argument-preview-stakes-are-high-in-dispute-over-rights-to-genetically-modified-seeds/ http://www.scotusblog.com/2013/02/argument-preview-stakes-ar...
- tellarin 14y agoBut the intended use of a piece of software is not to replicate itself (unless it is a virus). While the intended use of any seed is obviously to grow and reproduce. Hope the distinction is clear enough for the court. And this is a patent case, not a copyright one. On the other hand, I do think that copyright law needs to be revised in the case of digital goods that can be trivially copied/duplicated.
- belorn 14y agoWith businesses whose sole businessmodel depend on government to grant an state enforced monopoly, one should really ask if government shouldn't take a more active part in determining the benefit and cost of said model. When ever government go out and try to influence a market, they commonly do a cost-benefit analyzes. If they add a new regulation regarding health concerns in food processing, it is assumed that they do some form of balancing of cost and benefits. It is also assumed that we do not use the same cost and cost-benefit analyze they have laying around from the 19th century. Most people assume that what ever was true a few hundred years ago might have changed in the years and thus a new check regarding cost and benefits to society is in order. When government goes out using patents to influence the market to produce more inventions, they don't do a cost-benefit analyzes. They barely even use the 200 year old check regarding previous invention, obviousness and discovery, as the number of inventions has increase beyond what is human possible to check. They just grant the same sized 20 years state enforced monopoly to anyone who ask, and hope that any problems will be solved by the court system. The core of this case is how one should read the patent-exhaustion. It really shouldn't be about that. It should be about how and if the government should give aid to an company that invented, produced and successfully sold a grain that they modified with a discovered gene. It should be about the check and balance of the actions of government trying to influence the market with monopolies in an effort to encourage more inventions/discoveries regarding gene modified plants.
- ivan-p 14y agoThis is a must watch. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World_According_to_Monsanto http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World_According_to_Monsanto You can find it on youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fvGddgHRQyg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fvGddgHRQyg