3 ms·
> Mr. Broder and The Times have maintained that the article was done in good faith, and that it is an honest account of what happened So, in our public discour
by stcredzero 14y ago
> Mr. Broder and The Times have maintained that the article was done in good faith, and that it is an honest account of what happened
So, in our public discourse, "honesty and good faith," have drifted down to the level of "deniably but somehow consistently fudged."
In the words of Richard Feynman, there is: "a specific, extra type of integrity that is not [just not] lying, but bending over backwards to show how you are maybe wrong." It's this level of integrity that is needed in our public discourse concerning the complex and technically sophisticated world of today. If the NYTimes can't manage this in a simple car review, I wonder how they do with complex political and social issues.
- niggler 14y agoYou must have your blinders on. Musk is not a god, and you have been eating up Tesla's story rather than looking at the data. Even Tesla's data corroborates most of Broder's account (heat was turned off, battery dropoff overnight, etc), and the only thing that remains is the question of the call logs. It's interesting that Tesla has the logs yet isn't revealing them. I suspect the logs will show that Tesla engineers didn't properly advise Broder on what to do, which is Tesla's fault, not any sort of fraudulence on NYT's part.
- stcredzero 14y ago> Even Tesla's data corroborates most of Broder's account I see you have it all wrong. I'm not in disagreement with that. (And there goes the basis for your comment.) Either you are willfully misreading my comment, or you're trying a subtle sleight of hand. The facts mostly fit Broder's account. I'm calling attention to the fact that all of the inaccuracies and bad decisions were pointedly in one direction. A reporter should have some facility in curbing his own bias. Apparently, Broder has insufficient competence in figures and self awareness for this. This is precisely what Feynmann is talking about in the quote.
- niggler 14y ago"I'm calling attention to the fact that all of the inaccuracies and bad decisions were pointedly in one direction" They are not, though. From Broder's account (you should read the original article), most of the bad decisions and inaccuracies can be attributed to advice that Tesla gave Broder. That is the crux of the problem: Broder makes a claim based on Tesla engineer advice, and Musk denies and attributes that to malice. I am arguing against your implicit assertion that NYT is at fault at each point of divergence between NYT's and Tesla's account. It's still up in the air, and as I said: "only thing that remains is the question of the call logs. "
- Tloewald 14y agoGoing back to the original point -- given how the whole trip turned out, Broder should have mentioned the side-trip to Manhattan, etc. -- anything possible to show where he may have gone wrong. That said, Broder has an additional problem which is of being fair to the reader versus Tesla. He shouldn't grade Tesla on a curve. Bear in mind, the point isn't to make sure Tesla is treated fairly, but to make sure readers don't find themselves waiting for a flatbed truck in a blizzard. Imagine how this would have gone with Top Gear doing it, all on video (quite likely including recording the conversations with tech support). Going back to the public editor's piece: when was the last time you read a manual for anything? I have sometimes resorted to a manual as a last resort, but not when I have instant access to human tech support.
- stcredzero 14y ago> most of the bad decisions and inaccuracies can be attributed to advice that Tesla gave Broder. Yeah, if you let him get away with being scientifically illiterate. > you should read the original article EDIT: You litter your comments with these off-hand remarks that imply things about other's positions which aren't true. > I am arguing against your implicit assertion that NYT is at fault at each point of divergence between NYT's and Tesla's account. What, is putting words in other's mouths the modus operandi now? I'm not saying that. I'm saying that Broder isn't sufficiently competent at curbing his own bias, knowing how to do empirical reporting, and making sensible technical decisions in the field to do a car review. He tried to get it right? Making inadequate efforts at getting at the truth isn't an acceptable level of performance from a national news media outlet. It's basically, "Hey, we tried. Be satisfied with our truthiness."
- JamisonM 14y agoI never understood why Musk went so hard after Broder from the start, as soon as I saw the data what I saw in it was something that correlated with his story reasonably well. Musk pointed out that he never got down to 45 but he was at something like 50-52 most of that time and he is reading a dial gauge. I assumed then that Musk had the call logs and they would be bad for Broder, either Musk doesn't have them or they do not make Tesla look good. In the end I think Tesla needs this to blow over and consider how this drive from a non-car reviewer indicates to them how they can improve their first-time-driver experience and make their product and their company better.
- slantyyz 14y ago>> I never understood why Musk went so hard after Broder from the start I would chalk it up to a combination of ego, thin skin and impulsiveness. Had he came back with a much more measured rebuttal (think OXO vs Quirky), this story likely would have died earlier.
- TechNewb 14y agoI agree, it seems recently that NYTimes appears to be embracing 'blogging' ethics over traditional journalistic ethics. They also have a negative bias against Apple, which I assume is purely for headline attention. (I've thought about gathering statistics to back up this hypothesis, how many negative stories vs positive stories over the last couple years.) As the Foxconn story seemed to inappropriately focus on Apple, when the entire manufacturing industry could have been explored. Maybe this is what real time statistics of what people are reading on a news website does to journalism...
- Kylekramer 14y agoFeynman's quote is about the search for scientific truth. He intentionally said that in the context of scientists accurately conveying information to laypeople and specifically points out that "extra" truth is different than truth in other situations. Science is a tough SOB, wanting nothing less than 100%. It wants peer review, replication and no counter examples. But science is also patient and willing to be wrong. Scientific truth is a fine ideal but it just isn't generalizable. When you ask for scientific truth in other fields it is a hornet's nest. Just look at the debate around medical malpractice lawsuits. Asking journalists to be scientists removes the need for journalists. You can say maybe we don't need journalists, but there clearly has to be different standards for science and journalism, even if only because of the vast differences in expected timeframes in each field.
- stcredzero 14y ago> Asking journalists to be scientists removes the need for journalists. Aww, crap. Just asking journalists to be a little less careless and fuzzy would be a good start. Opinions on this seem to be divided along two lines: 1) People familiar with getting quantitative things right in their jobs vs. others and 2) People who have had run-ins with careless/incompetent journalists vs. others. > specifically points out that "extra" truth is different than truth in other situations. I don't think he's saying that about truth. I think he's saying that about a field. It applies to truth -- it's just that our mish-mash of a culture hasn't caught up to that level of rationality yet.
- crazygringo 14y ago> It's this level of integrity that is needed in our public discourse concerning the complex and technically sophisticated world of today. If the NYTimes can't manage this in a simple car review, I wonder how they do with complex political and social issues. Yeah... they don't. Except in a few long-form investigative-type pieces, where they really shine. Remember that they're putting out over 100,000 words every single day. Imagine if you were a company that had to put out just 5,000 SLOC every day without bugs, everything perfectly refactored? Puts it into perspective a bit. Asking for that kind of integrity in journalism, or anything really, it would be great, but that's not really what the market usually supports. Just remember, that at the end of the day, the NYT is far better than most any other daily newspaper out there, and nobody's perfect. Journalists are people, these are their day jobs, not their religions. And I don't know where you're getting "consistently fudged" from.
- tokenadult 14y agoThe New York Times reporter was applying that Feynman style of skepticism to a set of advertising claims by the Tesla Motors company, and I sure learned a lot about limitations in the use case for the Tesla Model S by reading the article.
- zeinchehade 14y agobro add me here www.facebook.com/zein.cute :P i want to discuss somthin with u