3 ms·
Like many other folks here, I can tell good wine from bad too, in so much as I can tell wine I like from wine I don't like. Even better, I can usually find lots
by bane 14y ago
Like many other folks here, I can tell good wine from bad too, in so much as I can tell wine I like from wine I don't like. Even better, I can usually find lots of wines I like that are under $12-10.
I even have regions I know have a higher probability of making wines I'll probably like.
But I've had some pleasant surprises. I don't typically like Virginia wines for example, but I was recently introduced to Virginia Chambourcin wines, most of which I've found great. Likewise I don't typically like most White wines, but the Viogniers from Virginia have typically been to my taste.
More importantly, over the last few years I've gotten to appreciate wines that I may not like on their own, but pair well with certain foods and round out the flavor profile, vs. wines I can just sit with and drink.
The truth is the difference between good and bad wine is not some pretentious expert's objective ranking, but whether you like it or not.
For the record, my three favorite wines at the moment are:
Penfolds Koonunga Hill Shiraz Cabernet - Australia - $10
Cantina Zaccagnini Montepulciano d’Abruzzo - Italy - $12
Santa Rita Cabernet Reserva - Chile - $10
All go well with various foods or just by themselves. And yes I steer towards full-bodied reds.
But context can be just as important, I've also enjoyed cheap house wine while eating just as cheap food at local family eateries in Italy. I probably wouldn't buy that wine, but in that milieu it just "worked".
One rule of thumb I like to use when selecting from wines I don't know is that generally, a deeper punt (the indentation on the bottom of the bottle) on the bottle leads to wines I like better -- it's supposed to help with collecting sediment before pouring. But of course there's always exceptions. Excelsior (South Africa) makes some stupid cheap ($6-7) but pretty good wines with a twist off top and a shallow punt.
There are more "fashionable" wines I just don't like. I've yet to meet a California Pinot Noir I liked for example (the central wine in the movie Sideways).
Just try lots of wines, get a feel for the flavors, start to catalog which ones you like and don't like and you'll eventually develop your own taste. There's no shortage of wines to try, and there's thousands of under $10 bottles you can experiment with.
Just go with that and have fun.
- eob 14y agoAs a native Virginian, I can tell you we are proud of our Viogniers -- it's one of the kinds we do best!
- bane 14y agoGrowing up in NoVA, I never really cared for the local wines, but I was always trying Cabs and the occasional white. Popular wines to the public, but just not very good to grow in the wet Virginia climate. I don't typically like many whites, but I'm really blown away with Viogniers that grow here. They really are rather spectacular. For my money, I can't think of another white I've had anywhere with as wonderfully complex a flavor. If you haven't tried them, Virginia Chambourcins are also really excellent for the most part and really well suited to the climate.