4 ms·

I think one of the points of the article is that the perceived 'goodness' of the wine comes from whether the wine is expensive or not. I don't remember where I

by sheri 14y ago

I think one of the points of the article is that the perceived 'goodness' of the wine comes from whether the wine is expensive or not. I don't remember where I read this, but packaging of a food product apparently has a non-trivial impact on the perceived taste. I asked a sommelier in Paris once about what makes a good wine. She told me "A good wine is one whose taste you like".

ImprovedSilence 14y ago
>>A good wine is one whose taste you like". Haha, indeed. I studied abroad in Italy, and one of my classes was a history and culture of food class, which included a day of wine tasting. I remember the "culture" part of that lesson was that Americans like their crazy expensive wine, simply because it is expensive, and fancy. Whereas Italy it is more generic, red or white, sweet or dry. Some go with red meat, others with fish. You go to the risterante, and pretty much get red or white "table wine", no expensive wine list or anything of the sort. The culture was not expensive fancy wine, just a good taste to compliment the flavors in your meal. Now, I've put down a good bit of wine in my time, but nothing quite hits the sport for me like an $8 bottle of Chianti. I can tell a difference in brands too, and have my favorites, but the price per bottle for a great wine never seems to need to go above $10.
- Evbn 14y ago
  Sweet or dry, maybe, but red and white taste the same in blind tests. (Not that there is anything wrong with wanting a color coordinated meal.)
  - bethling 14y ago
    I wouldn't say they taste the same - there's an overlap area with some where there would be confusion. But there will be whites that are simply not likely to be confused with reds, and vice versa. Though if you handed a white wine from that overlap area and colored it to look like a red. I'm pretty sure all but the experienced blind tasters would just accept it as being a light red. I am studying Enology at the moment, and have no doubt that I could be confused with the right wine. My pallet just isn't good enough. But having done enough bind tastings in the past I really feel like some wine types really do stand out enough to be recognized.

by sheri 14y ago

ImprovedSilence 14y ago

>>A good wine is one whose taste you like". Haha, indeed. I studied abroad in Italy, and one of my classes was a history and culture of food class, which included a day of wine tasting. I remember the "culture" part of that lesson was that Americans like their crazy expensive wine, simply because it is expensive, and fancy. Whereas Italy it is more generic, red or white, sweet or dry. Some go with red meat, others with fish. You go to the risterante, and pretty much get red or white "table wine", no expensive wine list or anything of the sort. The culture was not expensive fancy wine, just a good taste to compliment the flavors in your meal. Now, I've put down a good bit of wine in my time, but nothing quite hits the sport for me like an $8 bottle of Chianti. I can tell a difference in brands too, and have my favorites, but the price per bottle for a great wine never seems to need to go above $10.

Evbn 14y ago
Sweet or dry, maybe, but red and white taste the same in blind tests. (Not that there is anything wrong with wanting a color coordinated meal.)
- bethling 14y ago
  I wouldn't say they taste the same - there's an overlap area with some where there would be confusion. But there will be whites that are simply not likely to be confused with reds, and vice versa. Though if you handed a white wine from that overlap area and colored it to look like a red. I'm pretty sure all but the experienced blind tasters would just accept it as being a light red. I am studying Enology at the moment, and have no doubt that I could be confused with the right wine. My pallet just isn't good enough. But having done enough bind tastings in the past I really feel like some wine types really do stand out enough to be recognized.